LuxSci

Creating Secure Web Forms: What You Need to Know

person filling out a secure web form on a laptop

Creating secure web forms starts with creating a secure website. This process is more complex than creating web pages and adding an SSL Certificate. A certificate is a solid first step, but it only goes so far as to protect whatever sensitive data necessitates security in the first place.

Naive attempts at security can ultimately make the data less secure and more likely to be compromised by creating an appetizing target for the unscrupulous.

So, what do you do beyond hiring a developer with significant security expertise? Start with this article. Its purpose is to shed light on many of the most significant factors in creating secure web forms and how to address them. At a minimum, reading this article will help you intelligently discuss website security with the developers you hire.

person filling out a secure web form on a laptop

What Is Involved In Creating Secure Web Forms?

If you want to add a secure web form to your website, first, you must understand how to securely configure the website. Website security is a serious and complex topic; this article only discusses the high points. Check out some of our other articles and eBooks for more detailed information on website security.

Here are some of the critical issues that need to be considered:

  1. SSL – Is the website and form secured to transmit data from the end user safely? Is your website form page protected with SSL to prevent tampering with its contents?
  2. Web page content – Is the HTML content sent to the end-user protected from Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) issues, and does it avoid loading objects insecurely or from third parties?
  3. Script Security – Are the scripts or programs that process the submitted data written with security in mind? Do they have any vulnerabilities?
  4. Infrastructure – Is the website hosting provider trusted and known for good security? Are you on a shared server when you should be on a dedicated one?
  5. Data Flows – What do you do with the data once submitted? Is that data secured?
  6. Tracking – Do you track events such as data access and submission?
  7. Archival and Backup – Are there processes to make backups and permanent archives of important data?

SSL – Web Security Starts Here

SSL certificates are required for creating a secure website and form. The SSL certificate allows:

  1. The encryption of data sent to and from your web server and users to prevent eavesdropping or tampering.
  2. Your users trust that they are connecting to your website securely.

An SSL certificates on a properly configured web server encrypts your website data as it flows to and from your end users.

To get an SSL certificate, you can order one directly from a third party, or your web hosting provider will handle it for you. In either case, the web host will need to install the certificate on the server where the website is hosted, and then you will need to make changes to your site to take full advantage of the secure channel you have added.

SSL and Encryption

The most significant reason people use SSL is to encrypt the data transmitted from their website and the end-user. When an end-user visits a page protected by SSL, their web browser communicates over a secure channel with the web server so that all data transmitted is sent over this encrypted channel. This helps prevent eavesdropping and man-in-the-middle attacks on the data (more on these below).

Without SSL encryption, there is little or no protection of the data.

SSL and Trust

The most overlooked and misunderstood aspect of SSL is the establishment of trust. That is, enabling your end-users to trust and feel confident that they are connecting to your website. What else could they be connecting to, you may ask?

  1. Someone with access to the network between the end-user and website could be trying to intercept and read all the web traffic or altering your website pages themselves (e.g., changing your forms to submit the data to them instead of you). This is called a man-in-the-middle attack. Even with SSL security, a man-in-the-middle can present the end-user with an SSL Certificate for your domain name that looks legitimate, like a forged ID card.
  2. The user could be visiting another website that is pretending to be yours. This phishing website could collect information from your users for malicious purposes. Unless your users identify this site as illegitimate, they could be duped into revealing personal information. How could they end up at a phishing website like this? This can happen by clicking on a link emailed to them or by visiting a misspelled version of your URL. No site is immune from such attacks, but you can work to mitigate them.

SSL Certificates and Cybersecurity

As mentioned above, SSL certificates are not the sole website and form security solution, but they can help! To understand how it’s worth looking at how certificates are awarded. SSL certificates are signed by a third-party authority, the “Certificate Authority.” This can be:

  1. You, if you sign your certificates.
  2. A respected third-party issuing:
    1. A cheap or free certificate validating only your domain.
    2. A more expensive “Extended Validation” certificate which also validates your organization.

If you sign your own certificates, your website will generate warnings when anyone visits it. Users can choose to dismiss them, but more commonly, they will be more likely to navigate away from the website. For this reason, self-signed certificates are never recommended for a public website. Self-signed certificates provide no inherent trust that they are legitimate (anyone can generate one and pose as your site). They look amateurish and are annoying to the end user. Self-signed certificates should only be used in internal or test environments.

When ordering a certificate from a trusted third-party authority, there are various types that you can order. The cheapest ones are called domain-validated certificates. These work by emailing your domain administrator a validation link. Once verified, the certificate is awarded. These domain-validated certificates are acceptable and provide excellent security; however, as no humans are directly involved in the validation process, it may be easier for an attacker to get an illegitimate certificate by gaining control of the admin’s inbox or via other methods.

You can also order Extended Validation certificates. They cost more because real people validate the organization and your domain ownership. They make phone calls and ensure that everything looks right. If you have one of these certificates, your browser’s address bar turns green (or displays a lock symbol) when visitors come there to indicate that this site is trusted. If you want to maximize trust and make it easy for your end-users to identify your site as legitimate, you should use an Extended Validation certificate. These cost more but are well worth it in terms of security and trust. If EV certificates are outside your budget, you should still use an SSL certificate from some trusted third party.

Securing Web Forms with SSL

Once your website has an SSL certificate installed by a web host, your web pages can be accessed with addresses that start with “https://” instead of just “http://.” The “s” in “https” means “secure.” Note:

  1. When connected to a web page using a secure address like “https://yourdomain.com,” the web browser will show a lock icon to inform you that the connection is secure.
  2. Web pages that end in “.shtml” are not necessarily secure. The “s” means “server” (i.e., server-parsed page) and not “secure.” So, for example, “http://yourdomain.com/index.shtml” is not a secure page, but “https://yourdomain.com/index.html” is a secure page.
  3. With SSL enabled, you can access the same page securely and insecurely in many default web server configurations. Both “http://yourdomain.com/form.html” and “https://yourdomain.com/form.html” work and show the form — the only difference is the use of SSL or not.

So, let’s say that you have a web form located at “http://yourdomain.com/form.html.” You have an SSL certificate, and your web host has installed it. Next, you want to:

  1. Make sure people connect securely to the form page.
  2. Make sure that no one can connect to the form page insecurely.

These two goals might sound the same, but they are not.

Enforce Secure Connections to Form Pages

Since regular website pages may be insecure, you need to ensure that the links to the secure form page are absolute links starting with the prefix “https://.” This will ensure that anyone clicking these links will be taken to the form page on a secure connection.

The best solution is to use an HSTS (HTTP Strict Transport Security), which tells browsers that they should always use the secure version of your website. If you choose to have both the insecure (http) and secure (https) versions of your site running at the same time (not recommended), then you need to be careful with linking so that sensitive pages are secured:

Wrong Links: Relative links are not recommended because, if the user is on an insecure page, relative links will always take them to insecure versions of the destination page. So relative links like the following should be avoided:

Fill out my form!

Correct Links: Absolute links will ensure a secure connection by specifying that SSL must be used via the link prefix “https://.”

For example: <a href=”https://yourdomain.com/form.html”>Fill out my form!

Be sure that all links to all secure pages of the site use this secure format with the “https://” prefix.

Side Note: These days, it is recommended that you use SSL for all website pages, not just ones that process sensitive information. This is good for user trust, security, and privacy. It is also good for Search Engine Optimization (as Google will reward you for securing your site). If you set up your site so all pages are always secure, relative links are safe.

Ensure No One Can Connect to Form Pages Insecurely

Using the above suggestions, all the links on your website will take users to the secure version of the form. However, most web hosts leave the insecure version of the form there, and users can still access it if they enter the insecure address directly (or if links are directed to the insecure page). As a next step, you should ensure that accessing the form page via an insecure connection is impossible.

There are several different ways that this can be done. Some of these include:

Separate space for SSL pages: If your web host has this feature, you can configure the website to store web pages for secure (SSL) connections in a different directory from those for insecure pages. If this feature is enabled, the form page is placed in the secure directory and no copies are in the insecure directory. Thus, any insecure requests for these pages would result in a “page not found” error. You could then implement server-side redirection rules where if someone requests the insecure page, they are automatically redirected to the secure version (this can be done using .htaccess files and the “Redirect” directive). If you did this, secure and insecure requests for the page would take the user to the secure version with no errors, warnings, or issues for the end user.

Scripted pages: If the form page is generated by a server-side script (i.e., PHP, Perl, Python, or JAVA), then the script itself can determine if the request is secure or not (e.g., by looking at the server environment variables). For secure requests, it can render the form as usual. The user receives an error for insecure requests or is redirected to the proper secure location. 

Securing all pages: (Recommended) The site can be configured to automatically redirect all requests for insecure pages to the respective secure page. All pages will be secure, and any accidental/incorrect requests for the insecure pages will still get people to the right place. Security is greatly improved if you have set this up.

If my form is posted to a secure form processing script, why does it need to be secured?

This question is usually asked when a third-party manages the form processing. Is securing the form itself with SSL needed?

The answer is based on the following facts:

  1. The data sent from end-users to the server will be secure and encrypted during transmission. This is critical for creating secure websites and forms that require HIPAA compliance.
  2. Non-technical end-users will only know if their data is securely submitted once it is done. Many end-users will refrain from submitting sensitive data to an insecure form on your site.
  3. End-users cannot know if they are viewing your website or a phishing site or if eavesdropping and modification are happening. Many users will not trust the connection and will not want to submit their data through your site if it appears insecure.
  4. If your form page is insecure, it is straightforward for any malicious party to perform a man-in-the-middle attack to eavesdrop on connections, modify your form in transit to change what is collected and where the data is sent, and set up phishing sites. Your end-users can’t tell if this is going on.

If you do not secure your web form with SSL, it is vulnerable to attack. If nothing is going on, you can rely on transmission security. However, that minimal level of security is not recommended for production websites or anywhere that compliance is required.

Other Aspects of Creating Secure Web Forms

Proper use of SSL for encryption and trust is only part of creating secure website forms. You must be concerned with many other aspects to protect your users, your application, and your company’s reputation. These include (but are not limited to):

1. Cross-Site Scripting (XSS). Suppose you include dynamic content on your web pages (i.e., information submitted by other users or content submitted via form fields), and that content is not cleaned of JavaScript and HTML. In that case, bad actors could make arbitrary content appear on your website, capture user data, or worse. All data displayed should be clear of undesirable content (script tags, special characters, HTML, and other things). This is one of the most significant security issues with dynamic web pages across the internet.

2. Secure Server-Side Programming: The scripts and programs that accept and process the data from online forms must be created with security in mind. They must validate all submitted data as needed without making assumptions about its format and content. The scripts must not provide avenues for attacks like SQL Injection. Scripts must not use submitted content as actual filenames or URLs for remote loading content. They should log any strange errors or problems for later analysis. They should provide a mechanism for blocking undesirable actions or users from using the scripts.

3. Validation: Validation of all input data is part of the above two points. However, it is so essential that we will repeat it and go over some of the fundamental points:

  • If you validate submitted content, always perform your validation on the server side. Even if you use JavaScript to validate the data on the client side, you should always re-validate it on the server side. Why? Because people can get around JavaScript and submit arbitrary content directly to your scripts. The scripts should be prepared to handle that.
  • Always de-taint submitted data. What does that mean? It means never trust submitted data and take pains to ensure that the submitted data matches what you expect. For example, if you have a select list that sends your script a number as the value, do not assume you are getting a number. Instead, check that it is a numeric value or convert whatever is submitted into a number.
  • Remove disallowed content from the text submitted by users. Remove or block special characters, embedded codes, and other things that should not be there.
  • Ensure the submitted data is manageable enough to be used.
  • Do not assume anything — program defensively.

4. Preserving State with Hidden Form Fields or Cookies: If your program remembers information from one page to another by saving the data in hidden form fields, then your program must also ensure that the content of those fields was not tampered with. One good way to do this is to make a hash of all the data, together with a secret value, and include that hash in the form data. Then, when the form is submitted, you can recompute the hash and compare it with what passed from the form. If they match, you are okay; if they do not, the data has been tampered with. No one can break this scheme without knowing your secret value or breaking your hashing algorithm. This method can also be used to validate data saved in cookies. You can go further and use time stamps to prevent replay attacks.

5. Third-Party Applications: If you install programs from third parties on your website, you must ensure there are no known security issues with these programs, and you must be sure to update these programs as soon as new versions are released. If you let your website languish with an older, vulnerable version of a program, it will become a target for hackers as they constantly search the internet for such websites. Your site will likely be hacked in these cases, possibly causing loss of business, deactivation of your website, and tarnishing your website’s reputation. Using a third-party application is easy, but you need to select a good one that places the burden of keeping it updated on you. An exception is using a third-party application hosted by the third party itself. In these cases, the third party ensures that the program is continuously updated with anything needed to address any security issues. The burden is on them and not you. If you choose a good, respectable vendor, you should have no problems.

All these things, and more, are critical to developing a secure web application.

Securing the Form Data After Submission

Ensuring that users’ data is transmitted securely to your web server is critical, as is ensuring that your application is secure and will not be hacked. To secure sensitive data, you must understand what happens to that data after your program receives it. Many people forget that transmitting the data from the web server may require just as much preparation as receiving it from their users in the first place.

In the following subsections, we will look at three different ways of saving and retrieving your users’ data. In each case, we will explain what is needed to secure the data in your systems.

Send Form Data via Email 

The most common action data processing scripts do is email the submitted data to the website owner’s email address. The website owner knows when there are new submissions by checking their email and can access the data immediately. Most people running websites check their email reasonably often, which integrates well with their business operations.

However, the standard ways of sending emails are entirely insecure. So, how can you use email while ensuring the data is secure and viewable only by the intended recipient?

  1. Have your website script encrypt the data.
  2. Send this encrypted data (or a link to download the encrypted data) to the intended viewers via regular email.

As the form data is encrypted within the email message, most insecurities inherent in email are obviated. You can also use secure third-party services to have your form data emailed to you securely without programming anything yourself.

Save the Submission in a Database

Many website owners like to save the submitted form data in a database (even if it is also emailed to someone). Why?

  1. The data is saved online and potentially accessible from anywhere.
  2. If the emailed copies of the data are lost, the copies in the database are still there.
  3. The database can be accessed through a web browser with a suitable user interface.
  4. The data is typically backed up and can be restored.

If storage in an online database is for you, then you need to:

  1. Use encryption, like SSL or PGP, to ensure the data is securely stored in the database. Why? The contents of database tables are not encrypted or secure in general. Storing unencrypted data makes it available to anyone with access to the database or its backups.
  2. Provide a user interface that allows you to access the database data. It must be secure, have robust access controls, and provide a means for decrypting the data.

The database option requires much work to make a secure and usable solution. For this reason, most small organizations do not end up using secure database storage for important form data.

Save the Data in Files

The file storage option is the “quick and dirty” alternative to secure database storage. Essentially, your program will:

  1. Make a file containing the form data.
  2. Encrypt that file using PGP or SSL.
  3. Save that encrypted file in a directory on the web server that is not accessible from the website. Another option is to save it in an online file-sharing service.

Then, the website owners can log in to the web server using Secure FTP and download these files as needed. They can be decrypted locally when the data must be accessed. Other simpler data access mechanisms are available if the files are saved in an online file share.

This solution is secure and provides an excellent backup to securely emailed data.

Other Technical Tips for Creating Secure Website Forms

There are many other considerations in developing and maintaining a secure website and forms. It would be impossible to cover or even list them all. However, here are some more interesting and valuable tips.

Use Secure Cookies

If your secure site uses cookies for anything, set the “secure” cookie and the “httpOnly” flags. This will ensure that these cookies are never sent insecurely over the internet when the visitor arrives at any insecure pages of your website (they are not sent at all to insecure pages) and thus helps preserve the security of the contents of these secure cookies.

Prevent Form Spam

Form spam occurs when automated programs find your web forms and try to send spam through them. Form spam can result in hundreds or thousands of useless form posts daily. Once you start getting form spam, stopping it is a priority. There are two primary ways to help prevent spam:

  1. CAPTCHA – This method requires end-users to read text embedded in an image and type that text successfully into a form field. The back-end program then validates this. Since most spam programs cannot read text embedded in images, it will successfully block almost all automated forms spam. However, CAPTCHA requires the users to perform one more step, which can be annoying.
  2. JavaScript and Cookies – Most automated form spam programs do not process JavaScript or use cookies. If your web form requires JavaScript to submit the form successfully, bots cannot do this, and most form spam will be blocked. This method is less reliable than CAPTCHA but does not require any extra work from the end-user. Note that if you wish to use the JavaScript method, you must be sure that arbitrary submissions to the default action URL of your forms will never succeed—only submissions made after the execution of your custom JavaScript should succeed.

Minimize the Need for Trust

A good rule of thumb is to minimize the need to trust third parties and trust only the trustworthy.

  1. If you do not trust your internal IT staff, do not host your web application on your servers or give them access to the server used.
  2. If you do not trust the third-party hosting your website, encrypt the form data as soon as possible. This helps ensure that the data is not saved anywhere in plain text and is not backed up in plain text, thus minimizing your exposure to unauthorized people. Further, ensure that the private keys and passwords needed to decrypt the data are not stored on the web host’s servers.
  3. Ensure that only authorized staff can access the submitted form data. Ideally, it should always be encrypted, and only authorized people should be able to decrypt it.

These are just a few obvious points. As you evaluate your web application and data flow, ask yourself, “Who can access the raw data and how?” at each stage. Are there stages where you are trusting people who should not be trusted?

Forced use of strong encryption in SSL

The strength of encryption used by SSL is a function of both the user’s web browser and the server. Even if your web server supports excellent encryption, like AES256, the user’s browser may choose a weaker level of encryption. Older versions of Internet Explorer are notable for choosing weaker encryption in the interest of speed.

You can modify your web server configuration so that only levels of encryption you approve can be used to access your site.

Use Two-Factor Authentication

Two-factor authentication is standard on very secure sites now. You require a password and something else (a code or token) to validate their identity. With both, the user can log in. Avoid using only SMS texting as the second factor, which is no longer considered secure.

Get Started Creating Secure Web Forms

Outsourcing your form hosting and processing can be the fastest and most cost-effective way to get started. LuxSci’s Secure Form was designed for security and compliance. Contact us today to learn more about protecting sensitive information online.

Get in touch

Find The Best Solution For Your Organization

Talk To An Expert & Get A Quote




A member of our staff will reach out to you

Get Your Free E-Book!

LuxSci High Email Deliverability Best Practices Paper

What you’ll learn:

Enter your email to download now!

We respect your privacy. No spam, ever.

Related Posts

Best HIPAA Compliant Email Software

What Is the Best HIPAA Compliant Email Software?

The best HIPAA compliant email software protects messages in transit and at rest, verifies identity with layered controls, records activity for audits, and connects cleanly with clinical systems. A service fits this description when encryption operates by default, authentication is strong but simple to use, logging is clear, and contracts map to HIPAA Privacy and Security Rule expectations so staff communicate without extra steps.

Why to seek out the Best HIPAA Compliant Email Software

Email carries scheduling details, follow ups, and billing questions from morning to close. The best HIPAA compliant email software keeps that flow steady by applying Transport Layer Security for server to server delivery and using message level encryption when a thread leaves trusted paths so only intended recipients can read the content. Identity needs careful handling through multi factor sign in, phishing resistant authenticators for sensitive roles, and session rules that make sense on shared workstations. Sender validation with SPF DKIM and DMARC reduces spoofing so patients and partner sites trust the name in the from line. When these elements run quietly in the background, teams move faster and errors linked to manual security steps fade.

Security Controls That Set Email Software Apart

HIPAA cites technical and administrative safeguards in 45 CFR 164.312 and 45 CFR 164.308. In practice this calls for access limits, audit trails, integrity checks, and transmission protection that does not rely on user memory. Default encryption policies remove guesswork during busy hours. Role based access narrows who can open attachments that carry imaging or lab data. Session timeouts that fit exam rooms and nursing stations reduce unattended access. The best HIPAA compliant email software turns these safeguards into daily behavior rather than optional features tucked inside menus, and that difference shows up in fewer service tickets and cleaner audits.

Contracts and Evidence

Any service that touches patient information requires a Business Associate Agreement with clear duties for data handling, incident reporting timelines, and return or deletion of information at contract end. Contract text needs to mirror access controls, audit controls, and transmission security in 45 CFR 164.312 along with administrative expectations in 45 CFR 164.308 so there is no gap between policy and reality. Independent examinations such as SOC 2 Type II or HITRUST provide outside confirmation that controls work as described, and written incident procedures with suitable insurance show preparation for hard days. Vendors that meet these barometers look much closer to the best HIPAA compliant email software because they can show how legal promises meet operational practice.

Integrations That Put Messages Into the Record

Care moves faster when messages land where work happens. Direct links to electronic health records place threads and attachments in the chart without copy and paste. Open APIs route patient replies and flags to the right queue so action follows quickly. Single sign on keeps access simple as clinicians move between rooms, and mobile access that preserves encryption and authentication lets providers respond away from a desk. When the inbox feels like part of the chart rather than a separate island, time spent juggling windows drops, and the best HIPAA compliant email software starts to feel invisible in the best possible way.

Administration and Support Built for Scale

Growth introduces rotating staff, new locations, and changing schedules. Administration needs clear role templates, delegated admin rights, and policy profiles that apply consistently across sites. Template management keeps patient facing messages consistent while allowing local details where needed. Support that guides DNS setup, archive import, and policy tuning shortens launch time and reduces rework. The best HIPAA compliant email software treats these operational pieces as first class concerns, which shows up later when a clinic adds a new line of service or merges with a partner and everything still works without a scramble.

Comparing the Best HIPAA Compliant Email Software

A focused pilot tells more than a long checklist. Test inside one service line and measure time to send a protected message, the rate at which patients open secure threads, and the steps needed to file conversations into the record. Track admin effort for onboarding, policy changes, and template updates. Review pricing beyond a seat line by including storage tiers, archive export, and support response times over a multi year term so totals stay predictable. Platforms that deliver encrypted transport, content protection when needed, dependable identity, complete logging, and clean connections to clinical systems will rise to the top, and that is where the best HIPAA compliant email software becomes easy to spot without naming vendors.

Budget Planning Without Surprises

Seat price rarely tells the whole story. Storage, export fees, and support commitments shape the total over time, as do retention rules that extend message life for legal or clinical reasons. Map these items to record policy and growth plans so expenses track reality. If a platform proves it can keep Protected Health Information private in motion and at rest, place messages into the chart without friction, and provide evidence that satisfies auditors, the decision gets simpler. In that situation the best HIPAA compliant email software supports daily communication while staying out of the way, which is exactly what busy clinics need.

How to Make Google Workspace HIPAA Compliant

How to Make Google Workspace HIPAA Compliant

Healthcare organizations can make Google Workspace HIPAA compliant by completing a Business Associate Agreement with Google, configuring advanced security settings, and training staff on proper data handling. Knowing how to make google workspace HIPAA compliant means understanding that compliance depends on both technology and human oversight. When these elements are managed carefully, Google Workspace can be used to handle Protected Health Information securely while maintaining efficiency and accessibility for healthcare teams.

The compliance framework

The process of learning how to make google workspace HIPAA compliant begins with recognizing that Google provides the infrastructure, but the healthcare organization is responsible for compliance. The HIPAA Privacy and Security Rules require administrative, physical, and technical safeguards that must be applied through policy and configuration. Google Workspace, when managed under the right plan, offers encryption, access management, and detailed audit logs. To make google workspace HIPAA compliant, administrators must use the business version, not free Gmail accounts, because only paid Workspace plans allow for proper control and a Business Associate Agreement. Documented internal policies should define how messages, files, and calendars containing patient data are stored and monitored. Establishing this structure early makes every later compliance step easier to maintain.

The importance of the Business Associate Agreement

A Business Associate Agreement (BAA) is an unskippable step in how to make google workspace HIPAA compliant. Without it, compliance cannot be achieved regardless of system configuration. This legal contract specifies how Google protects healthcare data, reports incidents, and assists with investigations. The BAA covers key Workspace tools such as Gmail, Drive, Calendar, and Docs but excludes consumer products like YouTube and certain AI-based features. Administrators should disable any unsupported tools to prevent accidental data exposure. Reviewing and maintaining this agreement is essential to keeping google workspace HIPAA compliant as Google updates or expands its services. Many healthcare organizations include the BAA in their annual compliance review to confirm it still reflects current practices and security requirements.

Configuring strong security and access controls

Knowing how to make google workspace HIPAA compliant requires more than signing documents. It demands careful configuration of security controls that align with HIPAA’s technical safeguard requirements. Encryption should be enforced for all email traffic, and administrators should ensure that every account uses two-step verification. Device management policies can prevent unapproved computers or phones from connecting to accounts that contain Protected Health Information. Access privileges should be based on job roles so that staff only view the data they need to perform their duties. Audit logs can record sign-ins, file access, and configuration changes, giving compliance officers a clear view of user activity. Each of these steps contributes to a google workspace HIPAA compliant environment that protects against both external threats and internal misuse.

Maintaining compliance through user awareness and training

Even the most secure configuration cannot replace good judgment. A key part of how to make google workspace HIPAA compliant is ensuring that every staff member understands their responsibility when handling patient information. Training should explain how to identify Protected Health Information, when encryption is necessary, and how to report security incidents. Consistent reminders help prevent accidental sharing or unauthorized forwarding of sensitive messages. Regular audits of user activity can identify risks such as unused accounts, weak passwords, or improper storage of files. By reinforcing awareness and accountability, organizations maintain their google workspace HIPAA compliant status while reducing the risk of human error that can lead to violations.

Compliance is not a static condition but a continuous process. Administrators who understand how to make google workspace HIPAA compliant know that monitoring and documentation are required to sustain it. Google Workspace offers audit reports, security dashboards, and alerts that track sign-ins and encryption status. Reviewing these reports ensures that no settings are altered without authorization and that user activity remains within policy limits. Keeping written records of policy updates, staff training, and audit results helps demonstrate compliance during inspections. These records also create accountability and give leadership confidence that the system continues to operate within HIPAA standards. With diligent monitoring, a google workspace HIPAA compliant setup can stay reliable even as teams and technologies evolve.

A lasting culture of compliance

Organizations that learn how to make google workspace HIPAA compliant build more than a secure system—they create a sustainable culture of responsibility. Google Workspace allows healthcare professionals to collaborate, communicate, and share resources efficiently while safeguarding patient data. Maintaining this balance requires consistent review of settings, updates, and employee practices. As new regulations appear and technology develops, compliance officers should revisit each requirement to ensure ongoing protection. A well-managed, google workspace HIPAA compliant configuration supports both privacy and productivity, proving that regulatory compliance and convenience can coexist when oversight and education remain priorities.

HIPAA Compliant Email

Top HIPAA Compliant Email Use Cases for Medical Equipment Providers

For medical equipment providers – particularly those offering in-home care and delivery – rapid and reliable communication is critical. Whether you’re notifying patients about a new CPAP machine, reminding them of a delivery appointment, or sending a promotional offer on home oxygen supplies, email is still one of today’s most effective communication channels.

But, does your current email provider put you at risk?

Here’s the catch: when emails contain health-related information, i.e., protected health information (PHI), you must ensure you’re not just being effective, but that you’re secure and fully HIPAA-compliant as well. 

The good news: When you use secure, HIPAA compliant email correctly, you can ensure data privacy and security, while unlocking faster communication, improved patient or customer engagement, and better outcomes.

And you may even sleep better at night.

Let’s take a look at the most impactful use cases for HIPAA compliant email in the medical equipment space, and how secure, high volume email can optimize both the patient experience and your operations.

Why Email for Medical Equipment Providers

From ordering groceries to reading financial statements, consumers, including your patients and customers, already use email regularly. It’s familiar, simple, and trusted – and it doesn’t require installing applications or learning new tech.

For healthcare companies manufacturing and delivering home medical equipment, email is a fast, direct, and convenient way to communicate with your patients and customers. When used effectively and, most importantly, securely, secure email simply works.

HIPAA Compliance: A Catalyst for Communication – Not a Limitation

HIPAA compliance is often considered a hurdle to effective patient engagement via email. Fear of falling afoul of HIPAA regulations, and suffering the consequences of doing so, medical equipment suppliers can be reluctant to include PHI in their communications, missing out on opportunities to better connect with patients with personalized messages and relevant health information.

With the right HIPAA-compliant email solution, such as LuxSci, you can:

  • Send a variety of health-related info via email containing PHI – securely
  • Automate email workflows, such as order confirmations and refill reminders
  • Deliver more relevant marketing messages to carefully segmented target audiences
  • Scale your patient engagement campaigns with 98% delverability

HIPAA Compliant Email Use Cases for Medical Equipment Providers

Let’s take a closer look at some of the most common HIPAA compliant email use cases for medical equipments providers – all with 

Use Case #1: New Product Releases and Equipment Upgrades

Why It Matters: Keep patients informed and engaged.

Launching a new model of your leading CPAP machine? New upgraded insulin pumps with Bluetooth syncing? You can use secure email to safely inform existing patients about relevant product innovations that support their care and overall healthcare journey. At the same time, you can market your products and use email to help drive and grow your business.

Benefits

  • Personalized product recommendations and new offers
  • HIPAA-compliant messages and content with patient-specific data
  • Maximise cross-selling and up-selling opportunities

Use Case #2: Promotional Offers and Special Discounts

Why It Matters: Drive revenue without compliance risk

Yes, you can send promotional content with PHI. As long as you use HIPAA compliant email and obtain proper consent from your patients, you can send special offers for products, such as CPAP filters, replacement parts, or orthopaedic braces – securely and effectively.

Benefits

  • Boost reorder rates and upsells
  • Reach patients with personalized, secure marketing messages
  • Stand out from competitors that send out generic communications

Use Case #3: Order Confirmations and Delivery Updates

Why It Matters: Keep patients informed and deliver a good experience

When patients rely on home deliveries for critical medical equipment and supplies, timely and relevant updates are vital. HIPAA compliant email allows you to securely send:

  • Order confirmations
  • Delivery tracking links
  • Equipment setup instructions

Benefits

  • Peace of mind for patients and caregivers
  • Fewer support calls
  • Improved delivery and overall patient satisfaction

Use Case #4: Appointments and In-Home Service Reminders

Why It Matters: Reduce missed appointements and optimize scheduling

Whether it’s a CPAP fitting, oxygen tank swap, or home nurse visits, appointment reminders keep patients informed and prevent delays in care delivery and schedules.

HIPAA compliant appointment emails can include:

  • Patient names and appointment details
  • Secure rescheduling links
  • Technician or home nurse arrival windows

Benefits

  • Fewer missed visits
  • Improved care continuity
  • Better coordination with caregivers
  • Enhanced patient satisfaction and trust 

Use Case #5: Payment Reminders and Billing Notices

Why It Matters: Accelerate revenue collection

Secure email makes it easy to send billing statements, insurance updates, or out-of-pocket payment reminders related to medical equipment and in-home care – even when they contain PHI or medical codes.

Benefits

  • Faster payment collections
  • Reduced billing confusion
  • Clear and compliant patient communications

Use Case #6: New Supply and Refill Reminders

Why It Matters: Promote adherence and retention

Don’t wait for patients to run out of critical supplies. Use automated, HIPAA compliant email to remind them it’s time to reorder medical products and/or supplies.

Benefits

  • Better patient outcomes
  • Higher reorder rates
  • Lower administrative overhead 

LuxSci HIPAA-Compliant Email for Medical Equipment Providers

HIPAA-compliant email is no longer optional, it’s essential, especially for modern medical equipment providers who want to provide the best possible experience for their patients, optimize operations, and retain an edge in an increasingly competitive healthcare landscape. 

For medical equipment providers delivering in-home care or direct-to-patient services, secure email enables smarter, faster, and more personalized communications – all in a secure, HIPAA compliant way on one of today’s most used communications channels.

With LuxSci, you can embrace email communication with confidence, safe in the knowledge that your messages are secure, compliant, and your emails are high-performing and effective. 

LuxSci Offers:

  • Automated encryption (TLS, Secure Portal Pickup, PGP, S/MIME).
  • SMTP and API integration, with EHRs, CRMs, and billing systems.
  • Automated workflows, for intelligent patient engagement.
  • High-volume email capabilities, for new product offers, upgrades, and promotions.
  • Signed BAA and full HIPAA compliance built in.

Whether you’re serving 100 patients or 100,000, LuxSci securely scales with you. Contact us to supercharge your engagement efforts today. 


Medical Equipment Providers Secure Email Use Cases FAQs

Can I send promotional emails about medical Equipment under HIPAA?

Yes, you can. With proper patient consent and a HIPAA-compliant email solution with a signed BAA, you can securely send personalized promotional messages.

Is it safe to include order or delivery details in emails?

Yes, when using a secure, encrypted email solution like LuxSci, you can send PHI, delivery info, and tracking links without violating HIPAA regulations.

Do patients need to log into a portal to read secure emails?

Not necessarily. LuxSci supports multiple delivery methods, including TLS-encrypted direct delivery and secure pickup portals, giving you and your patients options in regards to delivering and reading emails, respectively.

Can LuxSci help automate reminders and email flows?

Absolutely! LuxSci supports automated workflows, APIs, and integrations to trigger reminders, alerts, and follow-ups based on email engagement and recipient actions.

How does secure email impact revenue?

Secure email helps you increase reorder rates, reduce billing friction, and improve patient engagement, all of which can lead to increased revenue.

HIPAA secure email

Is Google Workspace HIPAA Compliant?

Google Workspace is HIPAA compliant when healthcare organizations use a paid Workspace plan, sign a Business Associate Agreement with Google, and apply the correct security settings. For organizations asking is google workspace HIPAA compliant, the answer is yes, but only after these specific requirements are met. Compliance is not automatic, but with proper configuration, the platform can safely store and transmit Protected Health Information in line with HIPAA’s Privacy and Security Rules. Healthcare providers can use Gmail, Drive, and related Workspace tools securely once they establish administrative controls, restrict access, and maintain appropriate user training to prevent data misuse.

What determines google workspace HIPAA compliant status

Understanding whether google workspace HIPAA compliant use is possible starts with how the platform is structured. Google provides a secure foundation with encryption, access management, and audit capabilities, but it does not control how each organization manages its users or data. Only administrators can apply the policies that bring the service into alignment with HIPAA requirements. To reach compliance, healthcare organizations must use Google Workspace business editions, not free Gmail accounts, because these versions provide enterprise-level controls. Once the paid version is in place, the organization must configure privacy settings, manage user roles carefully, and control external sharing. These actions determine whether data remains protected or becomes vulnerable to unauthorized access.

Why the Business Associate Agreement matters

A Business Associate Agreement, or BAA, is the foundation of compliance with Google Workspace. Without this agreement, the answer to is google workspace HIPAA compliant would always be no. The BAA outlines how Google protects patient data and clarifies responsibilities between both parties. It covers key services such as Gmail, Drive, Calendar, and Docs, all of which can store or transmit Protected Health Information. However, it does not extend to every Google product, and administrators must review which tools are included before use. Once the agreement is signed, the organization must ensure its staff follow the same security rules outlined within it. The presence of the BAA confirms that both the service provider and the healthcare entity acknowledge their shared responsibility for protecting data.

Configuring Google Workspace for HIPAA compliance

Even with a signed agreement, technical configuration determines whether the environment is secure. The question of is google workspace HIPAA compliant depends on how well administrators enable encryption, manage authentication, and restrict access. Encryption should protect messages in transit between servers, ensuring that patient data cannot be intercepted. Two-step verification must be activated for all users to prevent unauthorized account entry. Role-based access ensures employees only see the information relevant to their duties, reducing the potential for internal breaches. Audit logs track all administrative changes, giving compliance teams visibility into system activity. By enforcing these settings consistently, healthcare organizations create a protected workspace where privacy is built into daily communication.

The role of user management and internal policy

Technology alone cannot guarantee security. Determining whether is google workspace HIPAA compliant in practice comes down to how well users understand and follow internal policies. Staff must know what qualifies as Protected Health Information and how to handle it safely within the system. Administrators should set clear rules for when encryption is required, how to store shared files, and when it is acceptable to use email for clinical communication. Regular training sessions reinforce correct habits and prevent data from being shared through unsupported applications. When users are aware of their responsibilities, the platform functions as intended. Google Workspace then becomes not only a productivity tool but a secure channel for healthcare communication.

Practical limitations of using Google Workspace in healthcare

While Google Workspace can meet HIPAA standards, it still has defined boundaries. Some products included in the Google ecosystem are not covered under the BAA and therefore cannot store patient data. Tools that rely on machine learning or external integrations may process information outside the compliance framework. Healthcare administrators must evaluate each application before approving its use. Misunderstanding these limitations could result in unintentional violations. For example, using third-party add-ons connected to Gmail or Drive without verifying their compliance could expose sensitive information. Understanding these boundaries helps healthcare organizations use Google Workspace safely and maintain control over where data is stored and how it is accessed.

Making an informed decision about google workspace HIPAA compliant use

For healthcare organizations asking is google workspace HIPAA compliant, the real answer is that it can be, if implemented correctly. When the Business Associate Agreement is signed, encryption is enforced, and staff are trained, Google Workspace offers a secure and reliable communication platform. It combines ease of use with enterprise-level controls, making it suitable for clinics, hospitals, and business associates managing healthcare information. The key is to approach configuration and training as ongoing responsibilities rather than one-time tasks. With careful management, Google Workspace can support compliance while giving teams the flexibility to collaborate and communicate effectively across departments and locations.

You Might Also Like

Healthcare Marketing Compliance

What Is Healthcare Marketing Compliance for Medical Practices?

Healthcare marketing compliance involves strict adherence to HIPAA authorization requirements, state privacy regulations, and industry advertising standards when using patient information for promotional purposes. Medical practices must obtain written patient consent before incorporating protected health information into testimonials, case studies, or targeted advertising campaigns, while ensuring all business associate agreements with promotional vendors include appropriate data protection clauses and breach notification procedures.

Medical practices pursue new patient acquisition through promotional activities while protecting existing patient privacy rights. Marketing departments frequently discover that their most compelling promotional ideas involve patient stories, treatment outcomes, or demographic data that require extensive legal review before implementation.

Written Authorization for Healthcare Marketing Compliance

Patient authorization must precede any use of PHI in promotional materials, specifying exactly which information will be disclosed, identifying all recipients of promotional communications, and explaining patient rights to revoke consent. These forms require expiration dates, signature requirements, and plain language descriptions that patients can easily comprehend without legal expertise.

Organizations cannot combine promotional authorization with treatment consent forms or condition medical services on patients agreeing to promotional uses of their information. Patients who decline promotional authorization must receive identical treatment quality and cannot experience discrimination or reduced service levels because of their privacy choices.

State Privacy Laws

California’s Consumer Privacy Act, Texas Medical Records Privacy Act, and other state regulations impose requirements that exceed federal HIPAA standards for promotional activities. Some states require opt-in consent for all promotional communications, while others mandate specific disclosure language or waiting periods before promotional authorization becomes effective.

Multi-state healthcare systems must comply with the most restrictive state requirements across all their operations to avoid violating patient privacy laws. Organizations operating in states with enhanced privacy protections cannot rely solely on healthcare marketing compliance but must incorporate additional state-specific requirements into their promotional practices.

Digital Advertising Platforms

Social media advertising, email promotional platforms, and website analytics tools frequently request access to patient contact information, demographic data, or behavioral tracking that falls under privacy protection laws. Healthcare marketing compliance requires careful evaluation of third-party technology vendors to ensure they provide appropriate business associate agreements and data protection measures.

Retargeting campaigns that track patient website visits or online behavior present particular risks when healthcare organizations use advertising pixels, conversion tracking, or audience segmentation tools. These technologies may inadvertently transmit protected information to advertising networks without proper authorization or contractual protections.

Vendor Management Protects Marketing Activities

Advertising agencies, promotional consultants, and marketing service providers need business associate agreements before accessing any patient information for campaign development or audience analysis. These contracts must specify permitted uses of protected data, establish security requirements, and outline breach notification procedures when privacy violations occur.

Organizations retain full liability for vendor compliance failures, making thorough due diligence essential before selecting promotional partners. Healthcare marketing compliance programs should include vendor auditing procedures, contract review protocols, and performance monitoring systems to ensure privacy protection throughout promotional activities.

Content Creation Within Privacy Protection Guidelines

Patient testimonials, success stories, and case studies require detailed authorization forms that specify exactly how patient information will be used across different promotional channels and time periods. De-identification offers an alternative approach but requires removing all identifying elements according to HIPAA standards, including dates, locations, and demographic details that could reveal patient identity.

Photography and video content featuring patients or their treatment areas need separate consent documentation covering future use, distribution methods, and duration of permission. Healthcare marketing compliance includes behind-the-scenes content, facility tours, and staff interviews that might inadvertently capture patient information in background elements.

Staff Education Prevents Privacy Violations

Marketing personnel, communications staff, and external vendors need education about distinguishing between permissible healthcare communications and restricted promotional activities requiring authorization. Training programs should cover identification of protected information, authorization requirements, and escalation procedures for situations requiring legal review.

Updates cover new promotional channels, technology platforms, and changing regulatory interpretations that affect healthcare marketing compliance standards. Organizations benefit from establishing clear approval workflows for promotional materials and designating privacy personnel to review campaigns before launch.

Enforcement Actions Shape Compliance Priorities

Recent OCR investigations have targeted healthcare organizations using patient information in social media posts, email campaigns, and website content without proper authorization. These enforcement actions show increasing federal attention to promotional activities and willingness to impose financial penalties for privacy violations.

Settlement agreements frequently require organizations to implement comprehensive compliance programs, conduct staff training, and submit to monitoring for extended periods. Healthcare marketing compliance programs that consider these enforcement priorities can minimize violation risks and avoid costly regulatory investigations.

G2 Reports

LuxSci Earns 11 Badges in G2 Fall 2025 Reports, Including Best Support and Momentum Leader

We’re happy to share that LuxSci has once again been recognized for excellence in the G2 Fall 2025 Reports! Based entirely on verified customer reviews, LuxSci earned 11 G2 badges this season, highlighting our continued commitment to providing exceptional support, driving ROI for our customers, and delivering the best products.

 

From Best Estimated ROI to Momentum Leader, our performance on G2 is a direct reflection of the trust and success of our customers. Let’s take a closer look at what these new accolades mean and why they matter.

What Is G2 and Why Does It Matter?

G2.com is a trusted platform for peer-to-peer business software reviews. G2 publishes quarterly reports that analyze software companies based on verified customer feedback and real-world performance data. For the latest G2 reports, we’re honored to have earned 11 badges for Fall 2025.

Here’s What LuxSci Earned in Fall 2025

LuxSci was awarded a total of 11 badges across multiple categories. These honors reflect customer satisfaction, platform momentum, return on investment, and the quality of support we provide.

LuxSci’s G2 Fall 2025 Badges include:

 

  • Best Support (Secure Email Gateway)
  • Easiest Admin (Email Security)
  • Best Estimated ROI (Email Security)
  • Best Meets Requirements (Secure Email Gateway)
  • Momentum Leader (Multiple Categories)
  • High Performer (Email Encryption)
  • High Performer (Secure Email Gateway)
  • High Performer (Email Security)
  • Users Most Likely to Recommend (Secure Email Gateway)
  • Easiest To Do Business With (Email Encryption)
  • Easiest Setup (Email Encryption)

Why These Badges Matter

Let’s break down a few of the key categories and why they’re worth calling out:

Best Support

This badge shows we’re not just responsive—we’re reliable, helpful, and proactive. Our support team works around the clock to ensure customers feel heard and empowered. It’s a core part of our offering and overall customer experience.

Momentum Leader

This badge is awarded to companies showing significant growth in customer satisfaction, web presence, and employee growth. It means we’re not standing still—we’re scaling smartly, with our customers and partners in mind.

Best Estimated ROI

This one’s big. It means LuxSci offers exceptional value. Customers see real results that justify the investment. This includes secure email with 98% deliverability rates that truly drive better engagement for your healthcare communications and campaigns.

Built for Security and Compliance

At LuxSci, we don’t just build HIPAA compliant, enterprise-grade secure email and marketing tools—we build trusted relationships with our customers and partners. Our focus continues to be:

 

  • Protecting sensitive data with the highest levels of security and compliance
  • Building the best products, so customers have peace of mind
  • Providing unmatched customer support, every step of the way

We’re Not Slowing Down Anytime Soon

With security threats constantly evolving and compliance demands increasing, the need for secure, HIPAA compliant email and communications has never been greater. Whether you’re in healthcare, or regulated industries like financial services, LuxSci is here to ensure your communications stay secure, high-performing, and supported.

 

We’re proud to serve a growing base of professionals who rely on LuxSci every day to keep their sensitive data secure. Want to see what the buzz is about?

 

Explore LuxSci on G2

 

Contact us today to see how we can help you!

HIPAA Compliant Marketing

What Is HIPAA Compliant Marketing for Healthcare?

HIPAA compliant marketing for healthcare refers to promotional communications that follow HIPAA Privacy Rule requirements when using or disclosing protected health information (PHI). Healthcare organizations can conduct marketing activities while protecting patient privacy by obtaining proper authorizations, implementing security measures, and ensuring all marketing communications meet regulatory standards for PHI protection. Healthcare marketing has changed dramatically with digital communication channels, yet patient privacy remains paramount. Organizations must balance effective marketing strategies with strict compliance requirements to avoid violations that can result in hefty penalties and damaged reputations.

Understanding Marketing Under HIPAA Regulations

HIPAA defines marketing as communications that encourage recipients to purchase or use products or services, with certain exceptions for treatment communications and health care operations. The regulation distinguishes between communications that require patient authorization and those that fall under permitted uses without authorization. Face-to-face marketing communications between healthcare providers and patients do not require written authorization under HIPAA rules. Similarly, promotional gifts of nominal value given during these encounters are permitted without further consent. Most other marketing activities involving PHI require explicit patient authorization before implementation.

Healthcare organizations must understand when their communications cross from permissible patient care activities into regulated marketing territory. Educational materials about treatment options generally qualify as health care operations, while promotional emails about cosmetic procedures usually require marketing authorizations.

Authorization Requirements for Healthcare Marketing

Written authorization forms the foundation of HIPAA compliant marketing for healthcare organizations. Patients must provide explicit consent before their PHI can be used for marketing purposes, and these authorizations must meet specific regulatory requirements to remain valid. Authorization forms must clearly describe what PHI will be used or disclosed, the purpose of the marketing activity, and who will receive the information. The form must also explain that patients can revoke authorization at any time and that refusal to authorize marketing communications will not affect their treatment.

Healthcare organizations receiving financial remuneration for marketing activities face stricter authorization requirements. When third parties pay for marketing communications, authorization forms must disclose these financial relationships and explain how patient information will be shared with outside entities.

Permitted Marketing Activities Without Authorization

Certain healthcare communications that might appear to be marketing can proceed without patient authorization under HIPAA. These include communications about the covered entity’s own health-related products or services, or communications for treatment, case management, care coordination, or preventive health programs. For example, hospitals may send newsletters about their own diabetes management programs or wellness initiatives without obtaining individual authorization. However, if the communication involves financial payment from a third party to promote their products or services, patient authorization is required.

Case management and care coordination communications also receive authorization exemptions when they promote health or wellness activities. Healthcare organizations can recommend disease management programs, wellness initiatives, or preventive care services without obtaining separate marketing authorizations.

Technology Solutions for Compliant Email Marketing

Email marketing platforms designed for healthcare must incorporate security features that protect PHI during transmission and storage. These systems encrypt communications, maintain audit logs, and provide controls that help organizations manage patient authorizations and preferences. Segmentation capabilities allow healthcare marketers to target specific patient populations while maintaining privacy protections. Organizations can send diabetes education materials to patients with relevant diagnoses without exposing individual health conditions to unauthorized recipients.

Automated opt-out mechanisms help healthcare organizations respect patient preferences and maintain compliance with both HIPAA and CAN-SPAM requirements. These systems track authorization status and automatically exclude patients who revoke consent from future marketing communications.

Managing Patient Data in Marketing Campaigns

HIPAA compliant marketing for healthcare requires careful handling of patient data throughout campaign development and execution. Organizations must implement policies that limit PHI access to authorized personnel and document all data usage for compliance auditing.Marketing teams need training on HIPAA requirements and access controls that prevent unauthorized PHI disclosure. Role-based permissions ensure that only personnel with legitimate business needs can access patient information for marketing purposes.

Data retention policies must align with HIPAA requirements and organizational needs. Healthcare marketers should establish schedules for deleting PHI when it is no longer needed for marketing activities and maintain documentation of data destruction for compliance records.

Compliance Auditing and Risk Management

Regular compliance audits help healthcare organizations identify potential vulnerabilities in their marketing practices and address issues before they result in violations. These assessments should review authorization procedures, data handling practices, and technology security measures. Risk assessment processes must evaluate both internal marketing activities and third-party vendor relationships. Business associate agreements become necessary when outside marketing companies access PHI, and these contracts must include appropriate safeguards and liability provisions.

Documentation requirements include maintaining records diligently to demonstrate commitment to HIPAA compliant marketing for healthcare activities and their ability to respond appropriately to potential breaches or violations.

replying to an email

Are Replies to Encrypted Emails also Secure?

Sending HIPAA-compliant emails is easy when you use an encryption solution like LuxSci. But what happens when someone replies to an encrypted message? Are the replies also secure? This is primarily a concern when using SMTP TLS as a secure means of email delivery. 

This article will explain how messages are sent securely, how replies behave, and whether they are secure and compliant. At the end, we provide some recommendations for how to balance security and usability. 

(more…)