Encryption is a critical security measure for protecting electronic protected health information (ePHI) included within email communications, and a key technical safeguard under the HIPAA Security Rule. However, despite its efficacy in helping protect sensitive patient data from malicious actors, encryption can be difficult to successfully implement. 

Technical complexity, user resistance, and compatibility issues across different email systems can emerge as persistent problems, leading to frustration, risky workarounds, and, ultimately, increased risk of ePHI exposure and compliance violations. Without thoughtful deployment and support, encryption can become a barrier to successful secure email communication in healthcare, as opposed to a measure that underpins it.

To help you ensure secure, HIPAA compliant email communication, this post discusses the main encryption challenges you’re likely to encounter, how they can diminish your email security posture, and the measures you can take to overcome them. 

What Is Email Encryption?

Before we discuss the most frequent email encryption challenges faced by healthcare organizations, here’s a quick refresher on what email encryption is and why it’s so important for securing sensitive patient data.  

Email encryption is the process of scrambling the content of a message to make it unreadable as it’s sent to recipients or stored in a database. Only the intended recipient, who has the encryption key, can decrypt the email and access the data within. 

Consequently, in the event an encrypted message is intercepted by malicious actors in transit or exfiltrated from a data store during a security breach, they won’t be able to make sense of it. This renders any ePHI included in the message unintelligible and, therefore, worthless, adding another layer of security that preserves patient privacy – and keeps your business safe.

Common Email Encryption Challenges 

Let’s move on to detailing some of the most frequent encryption challenges that must be overcome by healthcare organizations to ensure secure email communication and HIPAA compliance. 

Decrypting Messages Is Too Difficult

The more difficult or drawn out it is for recipients to decrypt their email messages, the more likely they’ll simply go unread or end up deleted. If the decryption process is too cumbersome, which could include requiring a user to log into a separate site (i.e., a web portal), verify their identity multiple times, create a new account, or install additional software, it adds complexity. This can drive users to seek workarounds or cut corners, such as having information sent to them through unsecured channels, which puts your company at risk.  

Similarly, email clients, browsers, and security settings may impact the decryption process, causing compatibility issues that prevent users from accessing their messages. Within a healthcare setting, where timely communication is crucial, such obstacles can disrupt workflows, slow down patient care, and lead to HIPAA compliance violations if users resort to unencrypted alternatives. 

Encryption that Requires Manual Intervention 

Some email encryption tools require users to manually encrypt messages. If users forget to apply encryption or misconfigure settings, sensitive patient data could be exposed, leading to compliance violations and ePHI exfiltration. 

For employees who handle ePHI and need to send encrypted emails, remembering to enable encryption (vs. automated encryption) is an extra step that introduces the risk of human error into the process. To offer a related, and more relatable, example: how many times have you forgotten to include an attachment when sending an email, even when referencing the attachment in the message? It’s all too easily done. In the same way, an inexperienced, tired, or distracted user could simply neglect to turn on or correctly configure encryption before sending an email, putting patient data at risk. 

Increased IT and Administrative Overhead

The two email encryption challenges outlined above contribute to a third overarching difficulty for healthcare organizations: an increased workload for its IT, security and operations teams. 

First of all, IT, security and operations must establish and continuously enforce encryption policies, configuring rules that ensure sensitive patient data is encrypted while non-sensitive, business communication continues to flow unobstructed. Misconfigured policies can cause over-encryption, resulting in user inaccessibility and disruptions, or under-encryption, leading to exposure of ePHI and HIPAA compliance violations.

Second, IT support teams must troubleshoot user issues: namely employees and external recipients who are unfamiliar with encryption protocols and need support in overcoming difficulties in message decryption. These could be caused by compatibility issues between different email clients or systems, expired or missing digital certificates, incorrect key exchanges, or confusion surrounding accessing encrypted messages through portals or attachments.

Lastly, IT and governance teams must keep up-to-date with changing regulatory updates and email security threats. As compliance requirements evolve, healthcare organizations must reassess encryption standards, upgrade outdated protocols, and ensure that their workforce adheres to best practices. Without an adequate strategy and the right systems in place, managing encryption can become a constant drain on IT bandwidth, taking personnel away from other aspects of their work that contribute to patient care. 

Effective Strategies For Email Encryption

Having discussed the most common encryption challenges and how they can impact a company’s email security posture, let’s look at some of the most powerful mitigation strategies, which will improve the email encryption experience for both senders and recipients.

Balance Security With Ease of Use

To overcome the challenges of user inaccessibility, human error, and excessive administrative overhead, healthcare organizations must balance the ease of use of their encryption solutions with the level of security they provide. 

While opting for the most secure encryption protocols intuitively seems like the best option, extra security often comes at the expense of usability, which can render the encryption irrelevant if users decide to circumvent it altogether, as outlined earlier. Instead, it’s essential to evaluate the sensitivity of message content and select a corresponding level of encryption. 

Moving onto practical technical examples, Transport Layer Security (TLS) is a widely used email encryption standard, thanks to its ease of implementation and use, i.e., once activated, no further action is required by the user to encrypt the message content. However, TLS only encrypts ePHI in transit, i.e., when being sent to recipients, which may prove insufficient for highly sensitive patient data.

In contrast, encryption protocols such as Secure/Multipurpose Internet Mail Extensions (S/MIME),  AES-256 and Pretty Good Privacy (PGP) provide more comprehensive encryption, safeguarding the ePHI contained in email communications both in transit and at rest, i.e., when stored in a database. Now, while this makes them more effective at securing patient data and achieving HIPAA compliance, these standards are more complicated to implement and to use than TLS encryption. 

S/MIME requires users to obtain and install digital certificates from a Certificate Authority (CA), which verifies their respective identities and provides the public key for encryption. Consequently, both the sender and recipient must have valid certificates; if either party’s certificate is revoked or expires, they won’t be able to encrypt or decrypt the message, respectively.

With PGP, meanwhile, users must manually generate and exchange public/private keys. This offers greater flexibility than S/MIME but requires careful key management, which can be confusing for non-technical users. If a recipient doesn’t have the sender’s public key, they won’t be able to decrypt the message. Additionally, both S/MIME and PGP require a public key infrastructure (PKI), which can add considerable administrative overhead, particularly in regards to the management of certificates, public keys, and user credentials. 

Accounting for this, healthcare organizations can balance security with accessibility by employing a tiered encryption strategy: using TLS for lower-risk communication while opting for S/MIME or PGP for more sensitive communications.  

Enable Automatic Encryption 

Subsequently, the challenge of balancing security with accessibility can be remediated by deploying an email delivery platform that not only removes the need for manual user intervention but also automatically applies the appropriate encryption standard based on message content and delivery conditions. Rather than relying on users to choose the correct method—or worse, bypass encryption altogether—modern email solutions like LuxSci can intelligently enforce encryption without affecting the user experience.

Many healthcare companies rely on TLS encryption because it eliminates the need for encryption keys or certificates, additional log-ins, etc. For this reason, it’s often referred to as  ‘invisible encryption’ for its lack of effect on the user experience. 

However, to be most effective, both the sender’s and recipient’s email servers must support enforced TLS (i.e., TLS 1.2 and above). In the event the recipient’s email server doesn’t support TLS, the email message will be delivered unencrypted or fail to send altogether, depending on the server configurations. Additionally, once the email is delivered to the recipient’s inbox, unless the recipient’s email infrastructure encrypts messages at rest, it will be stored in an unencrypted format. 

Consequently, while TLS is ideal for email messaging that doesn’t contain highly sensitive ePHI, it’s insufficient for all healthcare communication. To ensure the secure and HIPAA compliant inclusion of patient data in emails, healthcare organizations should opt for an email solution that supports automated, policy-based encryption, which can upgrade to S/MIME or PGP when necessary. This offers the combined benefits of optimal ePHI security, minimal administrative burden, and removing the need for staff intervention.

Invest in Employee Education

While a flexible encryption policy and deploying email solutions that support automation will go a long way towards overcoming email encryption challenges, these efforts can still be undermined if users aren’t sufficiently educated on their benefits and use. For this reason, it’s crucial that healthcare companies take the time to educate their employees on both the how and why of email encryption.  

Even the most advanced encryption systems can fail if employees don’t understand how to use them properly, as well as what to look out for in their day-to-day email use. Some aspects of email encryption, such as recognizing secure message formats or troubleshooting delivery issues, may still require user awareness. With this in mind, employee training programs should focus on recognizing when additional encryption measures are necessary, how to ask for assistance, the dangers of unsecured channels, and how to report suspicious activity in addition to the practical aspects of using your email delivery platform. 

Overcome Email Encryption Challenges with LuxSci

LuxSci is a leader in secure healthcare communication, offering HIPAA compliant solutions that empower organizations to connect with patients securely and effectively. With over 20 years of expertise, we’ve facilitated the delivery of billions of encrypted emails for healthcare providers, payers, and suppliers.

Luxsci’s proprietary SecureLine encryption technology is specially designed to help healthcare organizations overcome frequent encryption challenges and better ensure HIPAA compliance with powerful, flexible encryption capabilities. Its features include: 

• Comprehensive email encryption: ensuring the encryption of patient data in transit and at rest. 
• Automated encryption: “set it and forget it” email encryption guarantees security and HIPAA compliance – with no action required on the part of users once configured. 
• Flexible encryption: dynamically determining the optimal level of email encryption, as per the recipient’s security posture, job role and supported encryption methods. This makes sure messages are delivered securely while maintaining HIPAA compliance.

Ready to take your healthcare email engagement to the next level? Contact LuxSci today!