There are many crucial factors to consider when developing and executing successful healthcare communication campaigns. First and foremost, you must ensure the protected health information (PHI) under your organization’s care is handled securely, as mandated by Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) regulations, which begins with selecting the right HIPAA compliant email provider for your company’s needs.

With the right email services provider (ESP) in place, healthcare providers, payers, and suppliers can confidently use PHI in their patient and customer engagement campaigns – safe in the knowledge they’re aligned with HIPAA’s tight regulatory guidelines.

To help you choose the best HIPAA compliant email provider for your healthcare organization’s email outreach objectives, this post compares two of the most well-known HIPAA compliant services on the market: LuxSci and Zix Webroot (from here, simply referred to as Zix). 

Comparing each email provider’s performance on several criteria, we’ll help you decide which solution best fits the needs of your healthcare organization and will help you better engage with your patients and customers. 

LuxSci vs. Zix: Evaluation Criteria

In our evaluation of LuxSci vs. Zix, we’ll be using the following criteria: 

• Data Security and Compliance: undoubtedly the most important factor when it comes to ensuring HIPAA-compliant email communication within healthcare organizations, this reflects the extent to which each platform secures sensitive patient data as per HIPAA’s regulations. 
• Performance and Scalability: the email platform’s ability to facilitate high-volume email communication campaigns, which also, subsequently, encompasses the platform’s throughput and how well they’re able to scale in line with an organization’s needs. 
• Infrastructure: if the email service provider has the necessary security infrastructure in place to both adequately safeguard PHI and support bulk email marketing campaigns.
• Marketing Capabilities: if the platform provides features that allow you to personalize and refine your patient engagement strategies.
• Ease of Use: how easy each email service is to use; a deceptively important factor in light of the urgent need for employee cyber threat awareness training. 
• Other HIPAA-Compliant Products: if the platform offers complementary features that aid healthcare organizations with their broader patient engagement, and growth, objectives. 

Now that we’ve covered the criteria by which we’ll be assessing each email platform, let’s compare LuxSci vs Zix to determine which is the best fit for your company’s needs. 

LuxSci vs. Zix: How Do They Compare?

Data Security and Compliance

LuxSci prides itself on being a fully HIPAA-compliant email service provider, offering end-to-end, flexible, and automated encryption, giving it an advantage in the protection of patient data in the event of its exfiltration by cyber criminals. Additionally, LuxSci is HITRUST-certified, illustrating its additional commitment to data privacy legislation and the securing of PHI. 

Zix is also fully HIPAA-compliant and, consequently, enables the use of PHI to personalize your email communications. That said, Zix doesn’t offer as many encryption options as LuxSci. Most notably, Zix doesn’t enforce Transport Layer Security (TLS) encryption or enable automated encryption. The absence of these features means that a healthcare organization’s security teams must perform more manual oversight when it comes to encryption of PHI, increasing the chance of human error.

Performance and Scalability

While Zix supports large email campaigns and provides detailed reporting functionality, LuxSci is the more prudent choice for high-volume email marketing campaigns. 

LuxSci maintains the necessary infrastructure to ensure the reliable delivery of hundreds of thousands to millions of emails per month (i.e., throughput – 1000s of emails per hour), all while adhering to HIPAA’s strict guidelines on preserving patient privacy.

Infrastructure

In the same way that LuxSci have advantages over Zix on data security capabilities, it performs well in this category too, which makes sense, as the two factors are interwoven. 

While offering a range of customary multi-tenancy infrastructure setups, Zix doesn’t accommodate dedicated, or single-tenancy, infrastructure options – for companies who can’t afford to depend on the security postures of the companies with whom they share servers. Zix, in line with its ability to facilitate large patient or customer engagement campaigns, provides enterprise-scale scalability. 

Zix also provides high availability and robust disaster recovery capabilities, so healthcare organizations can retain their operational capabilities in the event of a cyber attack. Or, alternatively, an unforeseen physical disaster that compromises a company’s infrastructure (power outages, fires, storms, intentional damage, etc.).

That said, LuxSci possesses all these features in addition to more comprehensive single-tenancy options, scalability, and secure email hosting.

Marketing Capabilities

As with our comparisons of LuxSci against email platforms like Paubox and Virtru, it’s somewhat futile to compare each platform’s marketing capabilities – as neither LuxSci or Zix are marketing platforms, in the vein of Adobe Campaign or Oracle Eloqua, for example. 

That said. LuxSci provides a HIPAA compliant marketing solution, offering automation, for streamlining email marketing campaigns, and, personalization options, for more engaging email communication campaigns. 

Ease of Use

Both LuxSci and Zix perform admirably in this category, but the edge goes to Zix, as LuxSci implementations often involve the complexities that come with large-scale, high volume use cases.

LuxSci, however, is known for offering best-in-class customer support backed by HIPAA security experts, honed as a result of over 25 years of facilitating and supporting email communication strategies for healthcare organizations of all sizes. 

Other HIPAA-compliant Products

With secure texting functionality, secure forms for HIPAA compliant data collection, and secure file sharing, LuxSci ranks well in this category.  Zix, in contrast, provides only secure file sharing – though, because of Zix Webroot’s capabilities, offers superior secure file sharing to LuxSci. 

Get Your Copy of LuxSci’s Vendor Comparison Guide

To discover how LuxSci and Zix stack up against the other leading email providers on the market when it comes to HIPAA compliance, take a look at our Vendor Comparison Guide.  Evaluating 12 email delivery platforms, the guide offers comprehensive insights on what to consider when selecting a HIPAA compliant provider, and how to choose the best solution for you.

HIPAA email requirements include implementing administrative, physical, and security protections for electronic protected health information transmitted through email communications. Healthcare organizations must establish policies, provide staff training, implement encryption measures, maintain audit trails, and execute business associate agreements when using email systems that handle PHI to ensure compliance with Privacy and Security Rule obligations. Email communication has become indispensable for healthcare operations, yet many organizations lack comprehensive understanding of specific HIPAA obligations that apply to electronic messaging. Clear knowledge of these requirements helps healthcare providers maintain compliance while utilizing email efficiency for patient care and administrative functions.

Administrative Protection Requirements

Written policies must govern how healthcare organizations use email for PHI communications, including procedures for patient authorization, encryption standards, and incident response protocols. These policies should address all aspects of email usage from initial setup through message retention and disposal. Privacy officer designation ensures that healthcare organizations have qualified personnel responsible for developing email policies, training staff, and monitoring compliance with HIPAA email requirements. This individual must have authority to implement changes and investigate potential violations. Workforce training programs must educate healthcare personnel about proper email usage, patient privacy rights, and security procedures for PHI protection. Training should be provided to all staff who use email systems and updated regularly to address new threats and regulatory guidance.

Physical Protection Standards

Workstation security controls prevent unauthorized individuals from accessing email systems containing PHI through unattended computers or mobile devices. Healthcare organizations must implement automatic screen locks, secure login procedures, and physical access restrictions for devices used to access patient information. Device controls help healthcare organizations manage smartphones, tablets, and laptops used for email communications containing PHI. These controls should include encryption requirements, remote wipe capabilities, and restrictions on personal use of organizational devices. Facility access restrictions protect email servers and network infrastructure from unauthorized physical access. Healthcare organizations must secure server rooms, network equipment, and backup systems that store or transmit PHI through appropriate access controls and environmental protections.

Information Access Management Controls

User authentication systems verify the identity of individuals accessing email systems before granting access to PHI. Healthcare organizations must implement strong password requirements, account lockout procedures, and regular access reviews to ensure that only authorized personnel can access patient information. Role-based access controls limit email functionality based on job responsibilities and PHI access needs. Administrative staff might have different email permissions than clinical personnel, ensuring that users only access information necessary for their specific duties within the healthcare organization. Account management procedures ensure that email access aligns with current employment status and job responsibilities. Healthcare organizations must promptly remove access when employees leave and update permissions when staff change roles to prevent unauthorized PHI access.

Audit Control and Accountability Measures

Activity logging systems must capture detailed records of email access, transmission, and modification activities involving PHI. These logs should include user identification, timestamps, and actions taken to support compliance monitoring and potential breach investigations. Regular log reviews help healthcare organizations identify unusual access patterns, potential security threats, and policy violations related to email usage. These reviews should be conducted by qualified personnel who can recognize indicators of inappropriate PHI access or disclosure. Accountability documentation helps healthcare organizations track individual responsibility for email activities involving PHI. Clear assignment of user accounts and regular certification of access needs ensure that email usage can be traced to specific individuals when necessary.

Information Integrity Protections

Data validation procedures help ensure that PHI transmitted through email remains accurate and complete during transmission. Healthcare organizations should implement controls that detect unauthorized modifications to email content or attachments containing patient information. Backup and recovery systems protect email data from loss due to system failures, security incidents, or natural disasters. These systems must maintain the same security protections as primary email systems while ensuring that PHI can be restored when needed for patient care or compliance purposes. Version control measures help healthcare organizations track changes to email policies, system configurations, and security settings that affect PHI protection. These controls support audit requirements and help ensure that security measures remain current and effective.

Transmission Security Standards

Encryption implementation protects PHI during email transmission between healthcare organizations and external recipients. Healthcare organizations must evaluate their email systems to determine appropriate encryption methods based on risk assessments and HIPAA email requirements. Network security controls protect email infrastructure from unauthorized access and cyber threats. These controls include firewalls, intrusion detection systems, and secure network configurations that prevent attackers from intercepting or modifying email communications containing PHI. Message routing procedures ensure that emails containing PHI follow secure transmission paths and reach intended recipients without unauthorized disclosure. Healthcare organizations should implement controls that prevent accidental misdirection of patient information to wrong email addresses.

Business Associate Management Obligations

Vendor evaluation processes help healthcare organizations select email service providers that can meet HIPAA email requirements and provide appropriate security protections for PHI. These evaluations should include security assessments, compliance audits, and reviews of vendor policies and procedures. Contract requirements ensure that business associates providing email services agree to protect PHI and comply with HIPAA obligations. Business associate agreements must specify security requirements, breach notification procedures, and audit rights that healthcare organizations need to maintain compliance. Monitoring procedures help healthcare organizations verify that business associates continue meeting HIPAA email requirements and maintaining appropriate PHI protections.