LuxSci Achieves HITRUST Certification for Third Consecutive Term

Business Solutions, Company Announcements, Industry News
LuxSci
October 21, 2024

We’re thrilled to announce our latest data security achievements here at LuxSci! Once again, LuxSci has achieved HITRUST CSF® certification, following a multi-step process that includes a deep assessment, validation, and quality assurance analysis for a company and its products. Our 2024-26 certification marks the third consecutive time that LuxSci has received the 2-year HITRUST certification, meeting the rigorous standards set by the HITRUST CSF framework.

In related news, LuxSci, which is GDPR compliant, has also renewed its US-EU Data Privacy Framework (DPF) certification for the next 12 months. According to the certification, U.S. companies that participate in the DPF provide adequate levels of security for personal data transfers received from the EU within the scope of the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). This renewal enables us to support customers in Europe, while ensuring we meet the highest data protection standards for cross-border data transfers. For customers that do business in the EU and UK, LuxSci ensures data privacy is upheld in compliance with regulations.

Our latest security certifications are a testament to our continuous and unrelenting commitment to delivering the highest levels of data protection for healthcare communications. This includes securing email, marketing, text, forms and hosting—while also improving patient engagement and outcomes with the use of protected health information (PHI) in communications.

Why HITRUST Certification Matters in Healthcare

In the healthcare industry, protecting sensitive patient data is not just a legal requirement—it’s an ethical responsibility and an imperative for any company or organization in existence today. While HIPAA compliance establishes a strong baseline for safeguarding patient information, HITRUST certification takes data protection a step further. The HITRUST Common Security Framework (CSF) integrates multiple regulatory standards, including HIPAA, to provide a comprehensive approach to information security, privacy, and risk management.

For healthcare organizations—and larger companies and enterprises, in particular—partnering with a HITRUST-certified provider like LuxSci provides peace of mind. You can trust that our security controls not only meet HIPAA standards but also go beyond them to address the latest industry challenges and emerging threats—we do this constantly, year after year.

How HITRUST Enhances Data Security Beyond HIPAA

HIPAA establishes the essential requirements for securing protected health information (PHI), putting a solid, but basic foundation in place. HITRUST certification is recognized for going beyond the basics. Here’s how:

Comprehensive Approach to Risk Management: HITRUST CSF combines various security, privacy, and regulatory standards such as NIST, ISO, and PCI-DSS, providing a more robust framework for managing risks in healthcare.
Continuous Monitoring and Improvement: HITRUST requires organizations to continuously monitor and improve their security measures, ensuring that their defenses evolve alongside new threats and new technologies.
Tailored Security Controls: HITRUST’s framework scales based on the size, complexity, and nature of the organization, offering flexibility while maintaining a high standard of security.
Third-Party Validation: Achieving HITRUST certification involves rigorous third-party audits, which demonstrate that an organization’s security practices are not only in place but have been thoroughly validated.

The Benefits of HITRUST Certification for Healthcare

For healthcare providers, payers, and suppliers, the advantages of partnering with a HITRUST-certified organization like LuxSci are clear:

Streamlined Compliance: HITRUST certification simplifies compliance with multiple regulatory frameworks, reducing the burden of managing multiple audits and certifications.
Enhanced Patient and Customer Trust: By choosing a HITRUST-certified partner, you show patients, partners, and regulators that your organization prioritizes the highest levels of security.
Future-Proofing: HITRUST ensures that you’re not just up to date with today’s standards but prepared for future regulatory requirements and security challenges as they arise.

At LuxSci, we remain committed to delivering secure, scalable, and flexible HIPAA-compliant healthcare communications solutions that our clients can depend on for the highest levels of data protection.

If you’d like to learn more about LuxSci’s secure healthcare communications solutions—and how we elevate your healthcare data protection to the next level—contact us today!

Get in touch

Find The Best Solution For Your Organization

Talk To An Expert & Get A Quote

First Name

Last Name

Work Email

Phone

Company

Type of Inquiry

Company Size

Message (optional)

Acceptance

I consent to be contacted by LuxSci for this inquiry and other relevant content, products, and services. You may unsubscribe from these communications at any time. We're committed to your privacy. For more information, check out our Privacy Policy.

A member of our staff will reach out to you

Search

Get Your Free E-Book!

LuxSci High Email Deliverability Best Practices Paper

What you’ll learn:

Enter your email to download now!

We respect your privacy. No spam, ever.

How Automated Workflows Boost Engagement for Healthcare Marketing Campaigns

August 13, 2025
Pete Wermter

Due to the fact that it’s simple, instantaneous, cost-effective, and nearly universally adopted, email is an essential part of all healthcare marketing engagement strategies. However, consistent, personalized email engagement – particularly at scale – can be challenging.

Fortunately, Automated Workflows offer a solution, allowing healthcare companies to deliver the right messages to the appropriate individuals at the right time, based on their individual engagement with emails..

In this post, we’ll explore the concept of Automated Workflows, the considerable benefits they offer healthcare companies, and the variety of ways they can be used to increase engagement and result in greater satisfaction and better healthcare outcomes for your patients and customers.

What Are Automated Workflows?

An Automated Workflow is a sequence of actions, known as’ Steps’ in LuxSci Secure Marketing, that a Contact (i.e., a patient or customer) moves through over time, based on a series of pre-defined rules or triggers.

Each Step is programmed to automatically perform a specific function, such as sending an email or updating a Contact, when certain conditions are in place. These conditions could include:

A Contact opening a message.
A Contact clicking through on a link.
A specified amount of time having elapsed..
A data update via an API call

By evaluating conditions to initiate the appropriate Step, Automated Workflows facilitate more timely, consistent, and personalized communication with Contacts (patients and customers ). As a result, healthcare companies can effectively harness Automated Workflows to develop dynamic, personalized email engagement journeys that adapt according to your patients and customers’ needs and prior interactions.

What Are the Benefits of Automated Workflows?

Let’s look at the various advantages that Luxsci Automated Workflows offer.

Reduced Administrative Workload

Arguably, the most significant benefit of Automated Workflows is the extent to which they lower the administrative burden of email engagement campaigns for healthcare organizations.

First and foremost, Automated Workflows eliminate the need for an employee to manually send your Contacts messages. As well as the manual effort, it removes a great deal of thought from the process – as someone isn’t required to remember to send an email.

By the same token, this reduces the scope for human error, preventing the possibility of an employee neglecting to send an important message, sending it to the wrong person, or worse, accidentally exposing patient data, i.e., electronic protected health information (ePHI).

The effort that Automated Workflows reduce is typically repetitive work that staff are glad to be free of, giving them additional time to focus on tasks that provide greater value and better contribute to better patient care and/or the customer experience.

Enhanced Scalability

The time saved by employing Automated Workflows increases with the size of your Contact List and the scale of your engagement campaigns. In fact, enterprise-scale campaigns, with volumes of hundreds of thousands to millions of emails, are only feasible through the use of automation.

Similarly, Automated Workflows enable healthcare organizations to run differing, personalized email campaigns aimed at unique patient or customer segments. As well as automatically sending each message at the appropriate time, they provide tracking capabilities to determine the outcome of each message.

Increased Consistency in Communication

Because Automated Workflows remediate the risk of emails going unsent, they facilitate more timely and consistent communications with patients and customers. This makes healthcare providers, payers, and suppliers appear more reliable and consistent, building trust and greater levels of satisfaction from Contacts. More importantly, recipients are better able to track what’s happening with their healthcare and assume a more proactive role overall healthcare journey..

Finally, creating an Automated Workflow requires healthcare organizations to carefully consider how they communicate with different Contact segments. Namely, the likely journey, or communication path, different types of Contacts take, i.e., information they need to know at a particular stage in their healthcare journey, the optimal order in which information needs to be presented, etc. This allows healthcare companies to become more in-tune with their patients’ and customers’ needs, enabling them to craft more valuable email communications that boost engagement.

Personalized Healthcare Engagement

Perhaps the most significant benefit of Automated Workflows is that they enable adaptive, personalized engagement for healthcare marketing and communications campiagns. Instead of manually tracking where each Contact is in a given engagement sequence, or worse, merely having to guess, you know precisely where they are. Consequently, you’re acutely aware of their needs and the exact nature of the emails you need to send them next.

This, in turn, enables more effective Contact nurturing, i.e, strengthening your organization’s connection with each individual. When at its most effective, this may allow you to anticipate your Contacts’ needs, enabling you to send them communications, such screening or testing recommendations, educational materials, or product and service suggestions, that support their healthcare journey and enhance their quality of care.

Automated Workflow Use Cases

Automated Workflows are a powerful tool for increasing healthcare marketing and communications engagement because they can be applied to a wide range of use cases. Let’s take a look at some of the most common and impactful ways email automation can be used by healthcare companies.

New Product Announcements: keeping patients and customers in the loop on your company’s latest offerings, as well as improvements to existing products and services that are likely to be of interest, based on their data and past actions.
Personalized recommendations: suggesting products or services based on the recipient’s past purchases or engagement history.
Re-Engagement Campaigns: Automated Workflows can also be used to reconnect with Contacts with whom engagement has waned or was never completely established, sending them personalized messages to encourage specific actions or reignite interest.
New Member Onboarding: welcoming new patients or customers with a structured series of emails that introduces your services, provides technical assistance (where applicable), details subsequent steps, and explains how to get the most value from your products or services.
Appointment Reminers and Follow-Ups: sending reminders, care instructions, medication adherence advice, or details on how to book subsequent appointments, for instance, after a patient visit.
Patient Education Campaigns: taking patients through a structured curriculum on managing their medical condition or required lifestyle changes to improve their health..
Preventative Care Communications: proactively sending reminders for screenings, check-ups, vaccinations, etc., based on PHI such as a patient’s age, gender, health condition or lifestyle risk factors.

Milestone Communications: sending personalized messages to acknowledge birthdays, enrollment anniversaries, and other pertinent dates. These can also be combined with preventative care communications, to send recommendations or other advice, based on the contact’s age, for instance.
Feedback Collection: acquiring patient and customer feedback by sending follow-up surveys a set amount of time after a visit, procedure, purchase, etc.

How Automated Workflows Work in LuxSci Secure Marketing

To round off this post, let’s take a deeper look at how Automated Workflows work within LuxSci’s Secure Marketing solution. LuxSci’s Automated Workflows enhance your organization’s HIPAA compliant healthcare marketing and email campaigns by giving you complete control of:

When each email is sent
Which Contacts receive particular communications according to their behavior, needs, and other PHI-based attributes
Which engagement path or branch a Contact takes based on their email actions

Here’s a look at LuxSci’s Automated Workflows key capabilities in greater detail.

Smart Event-Based Branching and Conditions

You can branch Workflows to trigger targeted messaging based on a Contact’s attributes or certain engagement events, resulting in more relevant and effective healthcare journeys with more desirable outcomes.

User actions:
- Mailing list sign-ups
- Form completion
- Downloading a resource.
Time-based triggers:
- A set period after a visit or procedure
- A defined period of inactivity or lack of contact
- Milestones, e.g., birthdays, anniversaries.
Behavioral triggers:
- Email opens
- Clicking on links
- Visiting particular pages on a site or
- A lack of engagement with previous emails.
Transactional triggers:
- Purchasing a product or service
- Signing up for an event
- Order confirmations or shipping updates after a purchase.
API-triggered events
- Lab results or similar correspondence becoming available
- Changes to data in EHR systems, CDP platforms, or CRM systems..

Automated Segment Management

Automated Workflows can be used to dynamically add Contacts to segments based on demographics, past behavior, purchase history, and similar events. This enables more precise targeting and email personalization as they progress through specific Steps in each Workflow.

Navigation Across Steps

Automated Workflows are also capable of navigating Contacts across different Steps or completely different Workflows depending on engagement outcomes and updates to a Contact’s PHI. Better still, if a Step has already been visited, LuxSci Secure Marketing automatically prevents repetition and infinite loops.

Automate Your Healthcare Marketing and Engagement Efforts

LuxSci Secure Marketing is a HIPAA compliant healthcare marketing solution especially designed for the stringent security and regulatory requirements of the healthcare industry. Our solution enables healthcare organizations to confidently communicate with patients and customers at scale without risking compliance violations, driving increased engagement and boosting the ROI of their marketing campaigns in the process.

The latest version of LuxSci’s Secure Marketing solution with Automated Workflow functionality streamlines your company’s outreach efforts, saving considerable time, reducing human effort, and facilitating intelligent Contact management.

What’s more, LuxSci’s reporting capabilities empower you to carefully track the results of your healthcare engagement campaigns, gaining insights at every step, including:

Which Contacts received particular messages
Who engaged with email communication, and how
Precise points where drop-offs in engagement occur
The engagement achieved with each Step in the Workflow

To learn more about LuxSci’s Secure Marketing solution and how Automated Workflows boost engagement for your healthcare marketing and communications campaigns, contact us today.

How To Create a Healthcare Marketing Plan?

August 4, 2025
Erik Kangas

A healthcare marketing plan establishes strategic promotional activities, target audience identification, budget allocation, and compliance protocols to attract new patients while adhering to HIPAA privacy regulations and state advertising laws. Medical practices develop these documents to guide their promotional efforts across digital platforms, traditional media, and community outreach programs, ensuring all patient acquisition activities comply with healthcare privacy requirements and professional advertising standards.

Medical practices compete intensely for patient attention in saturated healthcare markets. Developing promotional strategies without proper planning leads to wasted resources, compliance violations, and missed opportunities to connect with patients who need specific medical services.

Target Audience in Healthcare Marketing Plan Development

Patient demographic research identifies age groups, geographic locations, insurance coverage types, and medical conditions that align with practice specialties and service offerings. Healthcare organizations analyze existing patient data to understand referral patterns, appointment scheduling preferences, and communication channel effectiveness for different population segments.

Competitor analysis reveals promotional strategies used by similar practices, pricing structures for comparable services, and market gaps that create opportunities for differentiation. This research helps practices position their services uniquely while avoiding oversaturated promotional approaches that fail to generate meaningful patient engagement.

Budget Allocation

Financial planning allocates resources across promotional channels based on expected return on investment, patient acquisition costs, and practice revenue goals. Digital advertising usually receives 40-60% of promotional budgets due to measurable results and targeted audience capabilities, while traditional media and community events receive smaller allocations.

Compliance costs including legal reviews, authorization management, and privacy training must be factored into promotional budgets to ensure all activities meet regulatory requirements. Practices that underestimate compliance expenses often discover their promotional activities violate privacy laws or professional advertising standards.

Digital Strategy to Drive Modern Patient Acquisition

Website optimization, search engine marketing, and social media presence are the core of contemporary promotional efforts outlined in every healthcare marketing plan. Practices invest in professional website design, patient portal integration, and mobile-responsive layouts to capture patients researching medical services online.

Content creation including blog posts, educational videos, and patient resources helps establish expertise while providing valuable information to potential patients. However, all content must avoid using patient information without authorization and cannot make unsubstantiated medical claims that violate advertising regulations.

Compliance Integration Protects Promotional Activities

HIPAA authorization procedures, business associate agreements with promotional vendors, and state advertising law compliance must be woven throughout every aspect of promotional planning. Healthcare marketing plan development includes legal review processes, privacy impact assessments, and staff training protocols to prevent violations.

Documentation requirements for promotional activities include consent forms, vendor contracts, and approval workflows that demonstrate compliance with healthcare privacy laws. Practices without proper documentation face significant penalties when regulatory investigations uncover promotional activities that violate patient privacy protections.

Community Outreach Builds Local Patient Relationships

Health fairs, educational seminars, and community partnerships create opportunities for practices to connect with potential patients through face-to-face interactions. These activities require planning to ensure patient privacy protection while maximizing promotional impact through relationship building and trust development.

Referral programs with other healthcare providers, local businesses, and community organizations can generate new patient leads when structured appropriately. Any financial incentives for referrals must comply with healthcare fraud and abuse laws to avoid legal complications.

Performance Measurement Guides Strategy Optimization

Patient acquisition metrics, appointment conversion rates, and promotional channel effectiveness data help practices evaluate their promotional success and adjust strategies accordingly. Healthcare marketing plan implementation includes tracking systems for website traffic, phone inquiries, and new patient appointments generated by different promotional activities.

Return on investment calculations compare promotional spending with revenue generated from new patients to determine which activities provide the best financial results. Practices use this data to reallocate budgets toward high-performing promotional channels while eliminating ineffective strategies.

Implementation Timeline

Monthly promotional calendars coordinate campaign launches, content publication schedules, and community event participation to maximize promotional impact while avoiding resource conflicts. Healthcare marketing plan execution requires detailed project management to ensure all activities launch on schedule and within budget constraints. Seasonal considerations including flu shot campaigns, wellness check promotions, and holiday health messaging opportunities require advance planning to capitalize on increased patient interest during specific time periods. Practices that plan these campaigns well in advance may achieve better results than those that react to opportunities without preparation.

What Does the HIPAA Marketing Rule Require?

August 1, 2025
Erik Kangas

The HIPAA marketing rule prohibits healthcare organizations from using protected health information for promotional communications without written patient authorization, defining promotional activities as communications that encourage patients to purchase products or services with financial benefit to the sender. Organizations can send treatment-related communications, appointment reminders, and health plan benefit descriptions without authorization, but any communication promoting third-party products, paid services, or revenue-generating activities requires explicit patient consent through properly executed authorization forms.

Healthcare providers regularly find themselves struggling with acceptable patient education and prohibited promotional activities. A simple newsletter about diabetes management becomes problematic when it includes advertisements for glucose monitors or pharmaceutical products that generate revenue for the practice.

The HIPAA Marketing Rule Authorization Framework

Patient authorization documents must contain sixteen specific elements including detailed descriptions of information to be disclosed, identification of recipients, expiration dates, and explanations of revocation rights. These forms cannot be combined with other consent documents and must use plain language that patients can easily understand. Healthcare organizations face penalties when authorization forms lack required elements or contain overly broad permission language.

Patients retain the right to revoke authorization at any time, forcing organizations to immediately cease all promotional activities involving that individual’s information. Organizations cannot condition treatment, payment, enrollment, or benefits eligibility on patients providing authorization for promotional purposes, creating clear separation between healthcare services and commercial activities.

Treatment Communications Bypass Marketing Restrictions

Healthcare organizations can discuss treatment alternatives, medication options, and care coordination services without obtaining separate authorization because these communications serve legitimate healthcare purposes rather than commercial interests. Appointment scheduling, test result notifications, and prescription refill reminders fall under treatment or healthcare operations exemptions from marketing regulations.

Face-to-face communications between providers and patients about treatment options is unrestricted, even when providers receive financial benefits from recommended treatments or services. Written materials distributed during these encounters may trigger authorization requirements if they promote specific products or services beyond the immediate treatment relationship.

Financial Incentive Distinctions Shape HIPAA Marketing Rule Compliance

Communications become subject to the HIPAA marketing rule when healthcare organizations receive financial remuneration from third parties for promoting their products or services. Pharmaceutical company payments for promoting medications, medical device manufacturer incentives, or referral fees from specialty services transform otherwise acceptable communications into restricted promotional activities.

Organizations must examine their financial relationships carefully to determine when communications cross from permissible healthcare operations into restricted promotional territory. Even nominal payments or gifts from third parties can trigger marketing authorization requirements for communications that mention or promote those parties’ products or services.

Business Associate Relationships Complicate Marketing Activities

Vendors creating promotional materials, managing patient outreach campaigns, or analyzing treatment data for commercial purposes need business associate agreements before accessing PHI. These relationships are difficult if the promotional vendors also provide healthcare services or when healthcare organizations share revenue from marketing activities with their business partners.

Organizations must negotiate appropriate contractual protections and ensure vendors understand their obligations under the HIPAA marketing rule before beginning any collaborative promotional activities. Liability for vendor violations remains with the covered entity, making careful partner selection and monitoring essential for maintaining compliance.

Digital Platforms & Modern Marketing Compliance Challenges

Social media advertising, email campaigns, and online retargeting involve sharing patient information with technology platforms that lack appropriate privacy protections. Healthcare organizations cannot upload patient contact lists, demographic details, or treatment information to advertising platforms without proper authorization and business associate agreements covering those platforms.

Website analytics, social media pixels, and advertising tracking technologies may inadvertently capture and transmit PHI to third-party platforms without appropriate protections. Organizations need controls to prevent accidental information sharing while still enabling effective digital marketing activities within compliance boundaries.

Enforcement Penalties Reflect Serious Violation Consequences

Recent Office for Civil Rights enforcement actions have resulted in multi-million dollar settlements for organizations that used patient information in marketing materials without authorization or shared PHI with advertising vendors without appropriate agreements. These cases highlight increasing federal scrutiny of healthcare promotional activities and willingness to impose substantial financial penalties.

Violations may stem from seemingly innocent activities like patient newsletters, social media posts, or website testimonials that inadvertently disclosed PHI without proper authorization. Organizations discover that good intentions cannot shield them from penalties when their marketing activities violate patient privacy protections under the HIPAA marketing rule.

Compliance Programs Minimize Violation Risks

Healthcare organizations benefit from establishing clear review processes for all promotional materials and patient communications before distribution. Designated privacy personnel can evaluate whether proposed communications require authorization, involve business associate relationships, or create other compliance risks under marketing regulations.

Staff training helps employees recognize the difference between permissible healthcare communications and restricted marketing activities. Education updates keep pace with new promotional channels, emerging technology platforms, and evolving interpretations of the rule’s requirements within changing healthcare and advertising landscapes.

Why Healthcare Insurers Should Send Explanation of Benefits Statements Via Email

July 30, 2025
Pete Wermter

Explanation of Benefits statements or EOBs are mission-critical communications for health insurers because they ensure transparency, help detect billing errors or fraud, and most importantly, keep patients informed about their benefits and related payments.

However, the most conventional method of sending out EoBs, traditional mail, has several drawbacks that can prevent important information about healthcare coverage from reaching the intended recipient. This can leave policyholders in the dark about their healthcare coverage, which can lead to confusion and dissatisfaction with their insurance provider when they receive an unexpected medical bill. This can also drive up inbound calls into your claims department or contact center.

Because Explanation of Benefits statements contain the protected health information (PHI) of policyholders, insurers are bound by HIPAA (the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act) regulations to ensure their secure delivery. Consequently, the risks inherent to sending paper EoB statements in the mail not only have security implications but also potential consequences for non-compliance.

With all this in mind, this post discusses why healthcare insurers should send EoBs to their policyholders via secure email instead of traditional mail. We detail the various benefits of making the switch to electronic EoBs, which include enhanced security, better adherence to compliance regulations, and the opportunity to save millions of dollars per month.

Protecting Patient Privacy

The primary reason that insurance companies should shift to email EoBs as opposed to traditional mail is that it’s far more secure. Sending an EoB via email drastically decreases the risk of protected health information (PHI) getting into the wrong hands. When sent in paper form by mail, an EoB could be:

Lost, stolen or damaged in transit
Delivered to the wrong address
Not properly deposited in a letter or mailbox, then stolen
Intercepted within the intended address by another individual who lives at or has access to the residence.

As detailed later in this post, email also allows for various controls and processes, which mitigate the risks of unsuccessful message delivery.

Most importantly, secure email provides data encryption, which safeguards the sensitive patient data within EoBs during transmission and when stored by rendering it unreadable to malicious actors who might intercept it. Physical mail, in contrast, offers no such protection, as someone who intercepts a paper EoB form can simply open it and freely read its contents.

Finally, secure email delivery platforms feature identity verification and access controls that enable healthcare insurers to restrict access to PHI to authorized personnel, limiting its exposure. They also provide auditing capabilities to track access to patient data, and quickly identify the source of security breaches.

HIPAA Compliance Benefits

Because sending an Explanation of Benefits statement via email is more secure, and better protects any patient data contained within them, this also reduces the risk of HIPAA compliance violations.

First and foremost, HIPAA regulations mandate that communications containing PHI, such as EoBs, must securely reach the intended recipient. By eliminating the risk of physical interception or non-delivery, and the compliance violations from a resulting security breach, insurers can better adhere to HIPAA regulations using email for sending EOBs. On a similar note, the security features built into a HIPAA compliant email platform, such as encryption, access controls, and audit logs, help insurers to satisfy the requirements of HIPAA’s Privacy and Security Rules in their compliance efforts.

Another considerable benefit of using secure email to send policyholders their EoBs, or, in fact, any communication containing PHI, is that it’s far easier to implement breach notification protocols. Email delivery platforms provide real-time tracking, so companies can pinpoint email message failures quickly and act accordingly. Similarly, intrusion detection systems and other cybersecurity measures that support email systems can enable faster detection and containment of data breaches.

In stark contrast, physical mail is far more difficult to track – and even those limited capabilities are reserved for more expensive delivery options. Consequently, security breaches via mail could go unnoticed for days or even weeks. If you’re unaware of a data breach, or have not yet contained or mitigated it, you’re then unable to inform all affected parties, resulting in further HIPAA violations.

Increased Deliverability Rates

By greatly mitigating the security risks presented by physical mail, i.e., the various ways an EoB could fall into the wrong hands, sending an EoB by email increases your ability to get more EOBs into the hands of policyholders, more quickly. At the same time, policyholders can make faster decisions regarding their healthcare.

The ability to track secure email gives you greater control over EOB deliverability, as it allows organizations to determine the cause of delivery failure and can also make subsequent attempts. Additionally, the process of determining the reason for the message delivery failures can also reveal security issues; the same process, however, is very difficult to achieve with traditional mail.

Here’s how the typical protocol for resending a secured email goes beyond what you can do with managing traditional mail delivery:

Determine the cause of non-delivery: verify that the intended recipient information is correct and check for issues like a full email inbox or security misconfigurations.
Don’t automatically resend: to avoid exposing PHI to the wrong person, confirm the intended recipient’s email address through an alternative verified channel, e.g., phone call, secure SMS, etc.
Log the incident: document the delivery failure, steps taken to determine its cause, attempts, etc.
Reattempt message delivery: if the investigation deems it safe, attempt message redelivery with the corrected information.

In the event that subsequent delivery attempts fail, it’s best practice to contact the individual to arrange the most convenient and secure alternative to deliver their EoBs.

Cost Savings

Simply put, sending Explanation of Benefits statements via email instead of traditional mail saves health insurers money – potentially lots of it. Processing EOBs from start to finish can cost health insurers one to two dollars or more per EOB. That’s a lot. The biggest opportunity for cost reduction is tied to the money saved on printing and mailing paper EoB statements. Additionally, the cost of administering the delivery of EoB forms, ensuring their delivery, etc., is lowered when it’s done electronically. Not to mention, resending EoBs in the event of their non-delivery is much easier and cheaper via email.

In a broader sense, increasing the deliverability and the success rate of sending EoBs helps a larger number of policyholders better understand the details of their insurance coverage, i.e., how it works, which services and procedures it covers, etc. As a result of their policyholders being more informed, insurers won’t spend as much time explaining policy details and cost breakdowns to their members, allowing them to divert the otherwise required resources to other areas of the business.

Reduced Carbon Footprint

Finally, it’s difficult to highlight the benefits of sending EoBs to policyholders by email without recognizing the positive environmental impact, too. Email EoBs cut down on paper, for both the forms themselves and the envelopes they’re mailed in. Then there’s the matter of the electricity and ink involved in printing them, the emissions produced in their delivery, etc. Opting to send EoBs via email reduces all these factors, which enables healthcare organizations to lower their carbon footprint and, where applicable, meet their sustainability obligations or goals.

Deliver EoBs More Securely, Reliably, and at Lower Cost with LuxSci

LuxSci’s Secure High Volume Email Solution enables healthcare insurance companies to instantly send Explanation of Benefits statements to policyholders at a massive scale, extending into hundreds of thousands or millions per month.

Our HIPAA compliant email delivery platform features:

Dedicated IPs that isolate critical transactional messages, such as EoBs, from other email traffic, allowing LuxSci customers to reach deliverability rates of 98% or more.
Real-time tracking for determining the delivery status of EoBs, as well as troubleshooting unsuccessful delivery attempts.
Flexible encryption through LuxSci’s proprietary SecureLine Technology, which automatically adjusts encryption settings according to the recipient to better ensure the protection of sensitive data.

What Are HIPAA Email Requirements?

April 11, 2025
Erik Kangas

HIPAA email requirements include implementing administrative, physical, and security protections for electronic protected health information transmitted through email communications. Healthcare organizations must establish policies, provide staff training, implement encryption measures, maintain audit trails, and execute business associate agreements when using email systems that handle PHI to ensure compliance with Privacy and Security Rule obligations. Email communication has become indispensable for healthcare operations, yet many organizations lack comprehensive understanding of specific HIPAA obligations that apply to electronic messaging. Clear knowledge of these requirements helps healthcare providers maintain compliance while utilizing email efficiency for patient care and administrative functions.

Administrative Protection Requirements

Written policies must govern how healthcare organizations use email for PHI communications, including procedures for patient authorization, encryption standards, and incident response protocols. These policies should address all aspects of email usage from initial setup through message retention and disposal. Privacy officer designation ensures that healthcare organizations have qualified personnel responsible for developing email policies, training staff, and monitoring compliance with HIPAA email requirements. This individual must have authority to implement changes and investigate potential violations. Workforce training programs must educate healthcare personnel about proper email usage, patient privacy rights, and security procedures for PHI protection. Training should be provided to all staff who use email systems and updated regularly to address new threats and regulatory guidance.

Physical Protection Standards

Workstation security controls prevent unauthorized individuals from accessing email systems containing PHI through unattended computers or mobile devices. Healthcare organizations must implement automatic screen locks, secure login procedures, and physical access restrictions for devices used to access patient information. Device controls help healthcare organizations manage smartphones, tablets, and laptops used for email communications containing PHI. These controls should include encryption requirements, remote wipe capabilities, and restrictions on personal use of organizational devices. Facility access restrictions protect email servers and network infrastructure from unauthorized physical access. Healthcare organizations must secure server rooms, network equipment, and backup systems that store or transmit PHI through appropriate access controls and environmental protections.

Information Access Management Controls

User authentication systems verify the identity of individuals accessing email systems before granting access to PHI. Healthcare organizations must implement strong password requirements, account lockout procedures, and regular access reviews to ensure that only authorized personnel can access patient information. Role-based access controls limit email functionality based on job responsibilities and PHI access needs. Administrative staff might have different email permissions than clinical personnel, ensuring that users only access information necessary for their specific duties within the healthcare organization. Account management procedures ensure that email access aligns with current employment status and job responsibilities. Healthcare organizations must promptly remove access when employees leave and update permissions when staff change roles to prevent unauthorized PHI access.

Audit Control and Accountability Measures

Activity logging systems must capture detailed records of email access, transmission, and modification activities involving PHI. These logs should include user identification, timestamps, and actions taken to support compliance monitoring and potential breach investigations. Regular log reviews help healthcare organizations identify unusual access patterns, potential security threats, and policy violations related to email usage. These reviews should be conducted by qualified personnel who can recognize indicators of inappropriate PHI access or disclosure. Accountability documentation helps healthcare organizations track individual responsibility for email activities involving PHI. Clear assignment of user accounts and regular certification of access needs ensure that email usage can be traced to specific individuals when necessary.

Information Integrity Protections

Data validation procedures help ensure that PHI transmitted through email remains accurate and complete during transmission. Healthcare organizations should implement controls that detect unauthorized modifications to email content or attachments containing patient information. Backup and recovery systems protect email data from loss due to system failures, security incidents, or natural disasters. These systems must maintain the same security protections as primary email systems while ensuring that PHI can be restored when needed for patient care or compliance purposes. Version control measures help healthcare organizations track changes to email policies, system configurations, and security settings that affect PHI protection. These controls support audit requirements and help ensure that security measures remain current and effective.

Transmission Security Standards

Encryption implementation protects PHI during email transmission between healthcare organizations and external recipients. Healthcare organizations must evaluate their email systems to determine appropriate encryption methods based on risk assessments and HIPAA email requirements. Network security controls protect email infrastructure from unauthorized access and cyber threats. These controls include firewalls, intrusion detection systems, and secure network configurations that prevent attackers from intercepting or modifying email communications containing PHI. Message routing procedures ensure that emails containing PHI follow secure transmission paths and reach intended recipients without unauthorized disclosure. Healthcare organizations should implement controls that prevent accidental misdirection of patient information to wrong email addresses.

Business Associate Management Obligations

Vendor evaluation processes help healthcare organizations select email service providers that can meet HIPAA email requirements and provide appropriate security protections for PHI. These evaluations should include security assessments, compliance audits, and reviews of vendor policies and procedures. Contract requirements ensure that business associates providing email services agree to protect PHI and comply with HIPAA obligations. Business associate agreements must specify security requirements, breach notification procedures, and audit rights that healthcare organizations need to maintain compliance. Monitoring procedures help healthcare organizations verify that business associates continue meeting HIPAA email requirements and maintaining appropriate PHI protections.

How To Overcome Email Encryption Challenges in Healthcare

April 14, 2025
Pete Wermter

Encryption is a critical security measure for protecting electronic protected health information (ePHI) included within email communications, and a key technical safeguard under the HIPAA Security Rule. However, despite its efficacy in helping protect sensitive patient data from malicious actors, encryption can be difficult to successfully implement.

Technical complexity, user resistance, and compatibility issues across different email systems can emerge as persistent problems, leading to frustration, risky workarounds, and, ultimately, increased risk of ePHI exposure and compliance violations. Without thoughtful deployment and support, encryption can become a barrier to successful secure email communication in healthcare, as opposed to a measure that underpins it.

To help you ensure secure, HIPAA compliant email communication, this post discusses the main encryption challenges you’re likely to encounter, how they can diminish your email security posture, and the measures you can take to overcome them.

What Is Email Encryption?

Before we discuss the most frequent email encryption challenges faced by healthcare organizations, here’s a quick refresher on what email encryption is and why it’s so important for securing sensitive patient data.

Email encryption is the process of scrambling the content of a message to make it unreadable as it’s sent to recipients or stored in a database. Only the intended recipient, who has the encryption key, can decrypt the email and access the data within.

Consequently, in the event an encrypted message is intercepted by malicious actors in transit or exfiltrated from a data store during a security breach, they won’t be able to make sense of it. This renders any ePHI included in the message unintelligible and, therefore, worthless, adding another layer of security that preserves patient privacy – and keeps your business safe.

Common Email Encryption Challenges

Let’s move on to detailing some of the most frequent encryption challenges that must be overcome by healthcare organizations to ensure secure email communication and HIPAA compliance.

Decrypting Messages Is Too Difficult

The more difficult or drawn out it is for recipients to decrypt their email messages, the more likely they’ll simply go unread or end up deleted. If the decryption process is too cumbersome, which could include requiring a user to log into a separate site (i.e., a web portal), verify their identity multiple times, create a new account, or install additional software, it adds complexity. This can drive users to seek workarounds or cut corners, such as having information sent to them through unsecured channels, which puts your company at risk.

Similarly, email clients, browsers, and security settings may impact the decryption process, causing compatibility issues that prevent users from accessing their messages. Within a healthcare setting, where timely communication is crucial, such obstacles can disrupt workflows, slow down patient care, and lead to HIPAA compliance violations if users resort to unencrypted alternatives.

Encryption that Requires Manual Intervention

Some email encryption tools require users to manually encrypt messages. If users forget to apply encryption or misconfigure settings, sensitive patient data could be exposed, leading to compliance violations and ePHI exfiltration.

For employees who handle ePHI and need to send encrypted emails, remembering to enable encryption (vs. automated encryption) is an extra step that introduces the risk of human error into the process. To offer a related, and more relatable, example: how many times have you forgotten to include an attachment when sending an email, even when referencing the attachment in the message? It’s all too easily done. In the same way, an inexperienced, tired, or distracted user could simply neglect to turn on or correctly configure encryption before sending an email, putting patient data at risk.

Increased IT and Administrative Overhead

The two email encryption challenges outlined above contribute to a third overarching difficulty for healthcare organizations: an increased workload for its IT, security and operations teams.

First of all, IT, security and operations must establish and continuously enforce encryption policies, configuring rules that ensure sensitive patient data is encrypted while non-sensitive, business communication continues to flow unobstructed. Misconfigured policies can cause over-encryption, resulting in user inaccessibility and disruptions, or under-encryption, leading to exposure of ePHI and HIPAA compliance violations.

Second, IT support teams must troubleshoot user issues: namely employees and external recipients who are unfamiliar with encryption protocols and need support in overcoming difficulties in message decryption. These could be caused by compatibility issues between different email clients or systems, expired or missing digital certificates, incorrect key exchanges, or confusion surrounding accessing encrypted messages through portals or attachments.

Lastly, IT and governance teams must keep up-to-date with changing regulatory updates and email security threats. As compliance requirements evolve, healthcare organizations must reassess encryption standards, upgrade outdated protocols, and ensure that their workforce adheres to best practices. Without an adequate strategy and the right systems in place, managing encryption can become a constant drain on IT bandwidth, taking personnel away from other aspects of their work that contribute to patient care.

Effective Strategies For Email Encryption

Having discussed the most common encryption challenges and how they can impact a company’s email security posture, let’s look at some of the most powerful mitigation strategies, which will improve the email encryption experience for both senders and recipients.

Balance Security With Ease of Use

To overcome the challenges of user inaccessibility, human error, and excessive administrative overhead, healthcare organizations must balance the ease of use of their encryption solutions with the level of security they provide.

While opting for the most secure encryption protocols intuitively seems like the best option, extra security often comes at the expense of usability, which can render the encryption irrelevant if users decide to circumvent it altogether, as outlined earlier. Instead, it’s essential to evaluate the sensitivity of message content and select a corresponding level of encryption.

Moving onto practical technical examples, Transport Layer Security (TLS) is a widely used email encryption standard, thanks to its ease of implementation and use, i.e., once activated, no further action is required by the user to encrypt the message content. However, TLS only encrypts ePHI in transit, i.e., when being sent to recipients, which may prove insufficient for highly sensitive patient data.

In contrast, encryption protocols such as Secure/Multipurpose Internet Mail Extensions (S/MIME), AES-256 and Pretty Good Privacy (PGP) provide more comprehensive encryption, safeguarding the ePHI contained in email communications both in transit and at rest, i.e., when stored in a database. Now, while this makes them more effective at securing patient data and achieving HIPAA compliance, these standards are more complicated to implement and to use than TLS encryption.

S/MIME requires users to obtain and install digital certificates from a Certificate Authority (CA), which verifies their respective identities and provides the public key for encryption. Consequently, both the sender and recipient must have valid certificates; if either party’s certificate is revoked or expires, they won’t be able to encrypt or decrypt the message, respectively.

With PGP, meanwhile, users must manually generate and exchange public/private keys. This offers greater flexibility than S/MIME but requires careful key management, which can be confusing for non-technical users. If a recipient doesn’t have the sender’s public key, they won’t be able to decrypt the message. Additionally, both S/MIME and PGP require a public key infrastructure (PKI), which can add considerable administrative overhead, particularly in regards to the management of certificates, public keys, and user credentials.

Accounting for this, healthcare organizations can balance security with accessibility by employing a tiered encryption strategy: using TLS for lower-risk communication while opting for S/MIME or PGP for more sensitive communications.

Enable Automatic Encryption

Subsequently, the challenge of balancing security with accessibility can be remediated by deploying an email delivery platform that not only removes the need for manual user intervention but also automatically applies the appropriate encryption standard based on message content and delivery conditions. Rather than relying on users to choose the correct method—or worse, bypass encryption altogether—modern email solutions like LuxSci can intelligently enforce encryption without affecting the user experience.

Many healthcare companies rely on TLS encryption because it eliminates the need for encryption keys or certificates, additional log-ins, etc. For this reason, it’s often referred to as ‘invisible encryption’ for its lack of effect on the user experience.

However, to be most effective, both the sender’s and recipient’s email servers must support enforced TLS (i.e., TLS 1.2 and above). In the event the recipient’s email server doesn’t support TLS, the email message will be delivered unencrypted or fail to send altogether, depending on the server configurations. Additionally, once the email is delivered to the recipient’s inbox, unless the recipient’s email infrastructure encrypts messages at rest, it will be stored in an unencrypted format.

Consequently, while TLS is ideal for email messaging that doesn’t contain highly sensitive ePHI, it’s insufficient for all healthcare communication. To ensure the secure and HIPAA compliant inclusion of patient data in emails, healthcare organizations should opt for an email solution that supports automated, policy-based encryption, which can upgrade to S/MIME or PGP when necessary. This offers the combined benefits of optimal ePHI security, minimal administrative burden, and removing the need for staff intervention.

Invest in Employee Education

While a flexible encryption policy and deploying email solutions that support automation will go a long way towards overcoming email encryption challenges, these efforts can still be undermined if users aren’t sufficiently educated on their benefits and use. For this reason, it’s crucial that healthcare companies take the time to educate their employees on both the how and why of email encryption.

Even the most advanced encryption systems can fail if employees don’t understand how to use them properly, as well as what to look out for in their day-to-day email use. Some aspects of email encryption, such as recognizing secure message formats or troubleshooting delivery issues, may still require user awareness. With this in mind, employee training programs should focus on recognizing when additional encryption measures are necessary, how to ask for assistance, the dangers of unsecured channels, and how to report suspicious activity in addition to the practical aspects of using your email delivery platform.

Overcome Email Encryption Challenges with LuxSci

LuxSci is a leader in secure healthcare communication, offering HIPAA compliant solutions that empower organizations to connect with patients securely and effectively. With over 20 years of expertise, we’ve facilitated the delivery of billions of encrypted emails for healthcare providers, payers, and suppliers.

Luxsci’s proprietary SecureLine encryption technology is specially designed to help healthcare organizations overcome frequent encryption challenges and better ensure HIPAA compliance with powerful, flexible encryption capabilities. Its features include:

Comprehensive email encryption: ensuring the encryption of patient data in transit and at rest.
Automated encryption: “set it and forget it” email encryption guarantees security and HIPAA compliance – with no action required on the part of users once configured.
Flexible encryption: dynamically determining the optimal level of email encryption, as per the recipient’s security posture, job role and supported encryption methods. This makes sure messages are delivered securely while maintaining HIPAA compliance.

Ready to take your healthcare email engagement to the next level? Contact LuxSci today!

Is Wix HIPAA Compliant?

December 18, 2024
Erik Kangas

Wix is not HIPAA compliant for healthcare websites that collect, store, or process protected health information. Wix does not offer Business Associate Agreements and lacks the necessary security features required for handling patient data under HIPAA regulations. While Wix provides user-friendly website building tools and basic security measures like SSL certificates, these features do not satisfy the requirements for healthcare data protection. Healthcare organizations need specialized platforms if they plan to handle protected health information on their websites.

Wix Platform Limitations for Healthcare

Wix website building tools focus on ease of use rather than healthcare compliance requirements. The platform uses shared hosting infrastructure that lacks the data isolation needed for sensitive health information. User authentication systems in Wix do not provide the access controls required by HIPAA regulations. Form data collected through Wix stores information in ways that don’t align with healthcare privacy requirements. The platform lacks audit logging capabilities to track who accesses patient information and when. Data backup systems do not include the encryption guarantees needed for protected health information. These structural limitations prevent Wix from serving as a platform for healthcare websites with patient data.

Business Associate Agreement Status

Healthcare organizations require Business Associate Agreements (BAAs) from any service provider handling protected health information. Wix does not offer BAAs for its website building platform or hosting services, making it legally impossible to use Wix for websites collecting or displaying patient information, regardless of added security measures. Wix’s terms of service do not address healthcare compliance or regulatory requirements, as the company focuses on general business and personal websites rather than regulated industries with strict data protection needs. Healthcare providers may assume website builders automatically support healthcare regulatory requirements without checking BAA availability.

Form Collection and Data Storage

Many healthcare websites collect patient information through online forms. Wix form builders store submitted information in ways that don’t meet HIPAA requirements. Form data typically resides in the Wix database without the encryption needed for protected health information. The platform lacks documentation about data storage locations and security measures applied to form submissions. Integration options for connecting form data to HIPAA compliant systems remain limited. Access to stored form data doesn’t include the detailed permission controls needed for healthcare information. These form handling limitations are challenging for healthcare websites that may need to collect patient information securely.

Acceptable Uses for Healthcare Organizations

Despite HIPAA limitations, Wix remains suitable for certain healthcare-related websites that don’t involve protected health information. Healthcare providers can use Wix for informational websites displaying services, provider details, location information, and general health resources. Marketing materials and educational content without patient-specific information work well on the platform. Healthcare organizations sometimes maintain separate websites, keeping public information on Wix while placing patient portals on HIPAA compliant platforms. This separation allows organizations to benefit from Wix’s user-friendly design tools for public-facing content while maintaining compliance for protected information.

Secure Alternatives for Healthcare Websites

Healthcare organizations have several alternatives for creating HIPAA compliant websites. Specialized healthcare website platforms include appropriate security measures and offer BAAs as standard practice. Content management systems like WordPress can be configured for HIPAA compliance with proper hosting and security implementations. Custom web development on compliant hosting environments provides maximum flexibility while meeting security requirements. Patient portal systems designed specifically for healthcare use include built-in compliance features. These alternatives typically require more technical knowledge or higher investment than Wix but provide the necessary security infrastructure for protected health information.

Website Compliance Assessment

Healthcare organizations should assess their website needs before selecting a platform. This process starts with determining exactly what information the website will collect and process. Organizations need policies defining what constitutes protected health information in their context. Security requirements should align with the sensitivity of information handled on the website. Budget considerations need to balance platform costs against compliance requirements and potential penalty risks. Technical resources available for website maintenance affect platform choices. This assessment helps organizations select appropriate website platforms and implement necessary security measures based on their needs

How Can I Prove an Email was Sent to Me?

January 16, 2024
LuxSci

Almost everyone has been in this situation: someone claims to have sent you an email message, but you look in your inbox and don’t see it. As far as you know, you never got it. How can you prove an email was sent?

How to Prove That an Email was Sent

So, where do you start? As the purported recipient of an email message, the easiest way to prove that a message was sent to you is to have a copy of that message. It could be:

In your inbox or another email folder
A copy in your permanent email archives

Sometimes, missing emails are caused by simple user errors. The obvious place to start the search is in your inbox and email folders. It’s also a good idea to check your email filtering and archival services. It’s possible that your email filtering system accidentally flagged the message as spam or sent it to quarantine. If it’s not there, check your email archival system. That should capture a copy of all sent and received messages.

Hopefully, that will solve the issue. If it doesn’t, it’s worth stepping back to understand where the email could have gone and where you should turn next to solve the problem.

What happened to the email?

In reality, there are only a few things that could have happened:

The recipient never sent the message.
The recipient did send the message, but it did not reach you.
The message did make it to you, but it was accidentally or inadvertently deleted (or overlooked).

Let’s begin with what you can check and investigate. Start your search soon. The more time that elapses, the less evidence you may have, as logs and backups get deleted over time.

Did the recipient actually send the message?

First, you should know that the sender could have put tracking on the message so that they were informed if you opened or read it (even if you are unaware of the tracking). In such cases, the sender can disprove false claims of “I didn’t get it!” If you are concerned about an email being ignored, use read recipients or tracking pixels to confirm email delivery.

If you never saw the message, do what we discussed above and start searching your email folders for it. It could have been accidentally moved to the wrong folder or sent to the Trash folder. If you have a folder that keeps copies of all inbound emails (like LuxSci’s “BACKUP” folder), check there too. Check your spam folder and spam-filtering system. Your spam-filtering system may also have logs that you can search for evidence of this message passing through it. Finally, check any custom email filters you may have set up with your email service provider or in your email programs. If you have filters that auto-delete or auto-reject some messages, see if that may have happened to the message in question.

The searches above are straightforward; you can do many of them yourself. Often, they will yield evidence of the missing message or explain why you might not have received it.

Maybe the email was sent but didn’t make it to you?

Email messages leave a trail as they travel from the sender to the recipient. This trail is visible in the “Received” email headers of the message (if you have it) and in the server logs at the sender’s email provider and your email provider. If you know some aspects of the message in question (i.e., the subject, sender, recipient, and date/time sent), you can ask your email service provider to search their logs to see if there is any evidence of such a message arriving in their systems. This will tell you if such a message reached your email provider. However, email providers can typically only search the most recent one to two weeks of logs. So, if the message in question was from a while ago, your email service provider may be unable to help you (or may charge you a lot of money to manually extract and search archived log files if they have them).

If your email provider has no record of the message or cannot search their logs, you (or the sender) can ask the same question of the sender’s email provider. If they can provide records of such an email being sent through their system, that will prove the email was sent.

The log file analysis provided by the email providers could also explain why you didn’t get the message. Your email address might have been spelled wrong, there could have been a server glitch or issue, etc. However, if the message was sent long ago, the chance of learning anything useful from the email provider is small. Also, if you use a commodity email provider such as AOL, Yahoo, Outlook, Gmail, etc., you may find it impossible to contact a technical support person and have them perform an accurate and helpful log search. Premium providers, like LuxSci, are more likely to support your requests.

The last thing you can do is have the sender review their sent email folders for a copy of that message. If they have it, that can indicate that they sent it and can reveal why you didn’t get it (i.e., wrong email address, content that would have triggered your filters, etc.). However, be wary. It is easy to forge a message in a sent email folder, so it should not be considered definitive proof that the message was sent. And, even so, just because the message was sent, it does not prove it ever made it to your email provider or inbox.

The recipient never actually sent the email message

If the sending event was recent, then the data from your email service provider can prove that the message did not reach you, but that doesn’t prove that it was not sent. The sender may claim that they do not have a record of sent messages and that their email provider will not do log searching, and that may also be true. At this point, you are stuck without a resolution.

While email is a reliable delivery system, there are many ways for messages not to make it to the intended recipient. Whether it was not sent or was sent and never arrived, the result is the same- no message for you. As a result, it’s best not to send legal notices or other important documents only by email. Using read receipts and other technologies when sending important messages can help increase confidence that an email was sent and received. Still, there is no foolproof way to guarantee email delivery.

How Do I Prove the Email Sender’s Identity?

A separate but related question is, how can I be sure the sender is who they say they are? Social engineering is rising, and cybercriminals can use technology to impersonate individuals and companies. If you are questioning whether the sender actually sent the message to your inbox (or if it is from a spammer or cybercriminal), it is necessary to perform a forensic analysis of the email headers (particularly the Received lines, DKIM signatures, etc.) and possibly get the sender’s email provider involved to corroborate the evidence. To learn more about how to conduct this analysis, please read: How Spammers and Hackers Can Send Forged Email.